Comment by Dominique Plihon

Economist. Spokesman of Attac France. President of Attac France Scientific Council.
Hamon est peut-être plus radical, dans son approche, il cherche à proposer un autre modèle. D'où son idée de revenu universel, qui part du principe que l'emploi se raréfie, ce qu'on peut constater effectivement. Mais je ne pense pas que ce soit la bonne solution. Il y a une demande de travail, c'est un besoin exprimé par la population. Le travail, c'est la participation à la société, à la cité. Et la valeur créée dans l'économie vient du travail. Le capital, pour reprendre des termes marxiens, c'est du travail mort.
Disputed source (2016)
Like Share on X 2y ago
Policy proposals and claims
votes Against
Statement relation verification history Unverified
No statement relation verification comments yet.
Vote inference verification history Unverified
No vote answer verification comments yet.

Quote authenticity verification history

Disputed The La Tribune source URL is an interview with Dominique Plihon and contains this passage in his answers, so the attribution is broadly correct; however, the page reads "Aujourd'hui, Hamon est peut-être plus radical..." rather than starting directly with "Hamon...", and the article is dated 19 January 2017, not 2016. So the submitted version is not an exact verbatim match as given. ([latribune.fr](https://www.latribune.fr/opinions/tribunes/le-ps-c-est-le-desert-de-la-pensee-economique-631706.html)) · YouCongress gpt-5.4-2026-03-05 · 17h ago
AI Unverifiable Could not verify the source URL because latribune.fr blocks AI WebFetch access (Claude Code unable to fetch). Other checks: - Author attribution: Dominique Plihon is indeed an economist and spokesperson for Attac France, so he plausibly would have given this kind of interview to La Tribune. The quote's content (Marxian framing of capital as "dead labor", emphasis on work as social participation, critique of Hamon's UBI from a left perspective) is consistent with his known intellectual profile. - Vote alignment: The quote clearly opposes UBI ("je ne pense pas que ce soit la bonne solution" — "I don't think it's the right solution"), which correctly aligns with the "against" vote on "Implement a universal basic income". - Year: 2016 corresponds to the Hamon UBI debate during the 2017 French presidential primary, which fits the content. Searched for more recent (2023-2025) Plihon statements on UBI but found none specifically on this topic. - Relevancy: Quote is on-topic and substantive about UBI. Marking ai_unverifiable solely because the source URL cannot be retrieved to confirm the exact wording. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-7 · 1mo ago
replying to Dominique Plihon