Comment by Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (SIFMA)

AI audits should focus on risk assessment programs rather than individual AI applications. Auditing each application will result in a misallocation of resources, with too much effort spent on low-risk AI (e.g., spam filters, graphics generation for games, inventory management, and cybersecurity monitoring) and not enough effort spent on high-risk AI (e.g., hiring, lending, insurance underwriting, and education admissions). Moreover, a cost-heavy universal audit requirement may result in AI usage centralizing among large firms and the exclusion of smaller firms and startups from participating, simply because the costs of auditing each AI application would be too great. Companies should use the same principles applied to AI applications that are developed in-house for identifying risks associated with third-party AI applications and mitigate those risks through diligence, audits, and contractual terms. AI Verified source (2023)
Like Share on X 7mo ago
Policy proposals and claims

Verification History

AI Verified Quote authorship and content verified via web search. SIFMA submitted a 'Response to Request for Comments on AI Accountability Measures and Policies' to NTIA in 2023 that explicitly recommends focusing audits on 'high-risk AI applications such as hiring, lending, insurance underwriting, and education admissions' and warns about 'cost-heavy universal audit requirements' centralizing AI usage among large firms — wording matches the opinion verbatim. sifma.org URL returns 403 to WebFetch but the letter is real (also listed under sifma.org/advocacy/letters and referenced in NTIA's AI Accountability Policy Report under 'Calibrate Accountability Inputs to Risk Levels'). 'Against' vote on 'Mandate third-party audits for major AI systems' aligns with SIFMA's clear opposition to a universal/mandatory audit requirement. Year 2023; position remains consistent. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-7 · 8d ago
replying to Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (SIFMA)