Comment by Matthew Guariglia

Police and other government use of this technology cannot be effectively regulated. Face surveillance in the hands of the government is a fundamentally harmful technology, even under strict regulations and if the technology was 100% accurate. [...] This federal ban on face surveillance would apply to increasingly powerful agencies like Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the Drug Enforcement Administration, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and Customs and Border Patrol. The bill would ensure that these and other federal agencies cannot use this invasive technology to track, identify, and misidentify millions of people. [...] This important bill would be a critical step to ensuring that mass surveillance systems don’t use your face to track, identify, or harm you. The bill would ban the use of face surveillance by the federal government, as well as withhold certain federal funds from local and state governments that use the technology.
AI Verified source (2023-04-04)
Like Share on X 3mo ago

Quote authenticity verification history

Verification History

AI Verified Verified: the supplied EFF URL is a Deeplinks Blog post titled "Enough is Enough. Tell Congress to Ban Federal Use of Face Recognition," credited to Matthew Guariglia and dated April 4, 2023. The quoted passages appear verbatim on that page with only omitted text between them, including the sentences at lines 128, 133, and 136-137. The stored author, date, source URL, and content match the canonical source. ([eff.org](https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/04/enough-enough-tell-congress-ban-federal-use-face-recognition)) · YouCongress gpt-5.4-2026-03-05 · 3d ago
Disputed The source URL is a real EFF article by Matthew Guariglia dated April 4, 2023, and it contains the first paragraph verbatim at line 132 plus the later sentences verbatim at lines 137 and 140-141. However, the submitted text is not a single continuous verbatim quote: the article has four intervening paragraphs at lines 133-136 that were omitted without any [...] marker, so the quote is materially stitched together as presented. ([eff.org](https://www.eff.org/uk/deeplinks/2023/04/enough-enough-tell-congress-ban-federal-use-face-recognition)) · YouCongress gpt-5.4-2026-03-05 · 5d ago
AI Verified Quote by Matthew Guariglia (EFF) arguing that government face surveillance cannot be effectively regulated and is fundamentally harmful even at 100% accuracy, advocating a federal ban applying to agencies like ICE, DEA, FBI and CBP, and withholding federal funds from state/local governments that use it. Source is the EFF Deeplinks post "Enough is Enough. Tell Congress to Ban Federal Use of Face Recognition." The eff.org URL returned HTTP 403 to direct WebFetch, but web search confirmed this post was authored by Matthew Guariglia and published 4 April 2023, calling for Congress to ban federal use of face recognition and promoting the Facial Recognition and Biometric Technology Moratorium Act (S.681/H.R.1404), with the ban applying to ICE, DEA, FBI and CBP — matching the quote's substance and the "fundamentally harmful" framing characteristic of EFF. Author attribution correct (Guariglia wrote the post); year 2023 accurate; quote relevant. Vote alignment: linked statement is "Ban the use of AI for mass surveillance"; Guariglia/EFF call for such a ban, so the "for" vote is correct. (Note: the stored author bio says "EFF activism director"; Guariglia is an EFF policy analyst, but the quote attribution to him is correct.) Quote is from 2023 and was kept as still relevant. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-8 · 10d ago
replying to Matthew Guariglia