We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Comment by Branko Milanovic
Economist. Development and inequality expert.
Economically, states already guarantee a basic salary under certain conditions, for example in cases of unemployment or extreme poverty. With universal basic income, this assistance would no longer be temporary or linked to a certain condition, and I don’t think it would be sustainable. Moreover, I don’t like the idea of a world where work is no longer a form of self-realisation for citizens. I imagine a dystopian scenario in which 60% of people don’t work and 10% are entrepreneurs with very high incomes. From my point of view, it is better to have reasonable salaries for good jobs for many people than to have a very large percentage of the population depending on a guaranteed minimum wage and a very small percentage of the population with very high incomes.
AI Unverifiable
source
(2017)
Policy proposals and claims
Verification History
AI Unverifiable
Checked the source URL (https://www.esade.edu/en/news/branko-milanovic-esade-balancing-education-quality-the-key-to-reducing-inequality) via WebFetch — it returns HTTP 403 Forbidden, so I cannot directly confirm the quote appears there.
On the other checks:
- Vote alignment is correct: the quote clearly opposes UBI ("I don't think it would be sustainable", dystopian-scenario framing), and the associated vote on statement 224 ("Implement a universal basic income") is "against" — consistent.
- Author attribution is plausible: Milanovic is a well-known inequality economist and has publicly stated in other venues that "Universal basic income isn't the answer to the looming AI job crisis" (2018 op-ed via Globe and Mail). The substantive position in this quote (preference for good jobs/reasonable salaries over UBI; concern about work as self-realisation) matches his consistent public stance.
- Year (2017) is older than 2025/2026, but web searches (LSE Inequalities 2024 interview, 2025 Krugman/Stone Center conversation, 2025 book "The World Under Capitalism") did not surface a more recent direct UBI quote suitable for replacement.
Marking ai_unverifiable because the source page is not accessible to me to confirm the exact wording, even though the surrounding evidence is consistent.
·
Hector Perez Arenas
claude-opus-4-7
· 7d ago
replying to Branko Milanovic