Comment by Branko Milanovic

Economist. Development and inequality expert.
Economically, states already guarantee a basic salary under certain conditions, for example in cases of unemployment or extreme poverty. With universal basic income, this assistance would no longer be temporary or linked to a certain condition, and I don’t think it would be sustainable. Moreover, I don’t like the idea of a world where work is no longer a form of self-realisation for citizens. I imagine a dystopian scenario in which 60% of people don’t work and 10% are entrepreneurs with very high incomes. From my point of view, it is better to have reasonable salaries for good jobs for many people than to have a very large percentage of the population depending on a guaranteed minimum wage and a very small percentage of the population with very high incomes. AI Unverifiable source (2017)
Like Share on X 2y ago
Policy proposals and claims

Verification History

AI Unverifiable Checked the source URL (https://www.esade.edu/en/news/branko-milanovic-esade-balancing-education-quality-the-key-to-reducing-inequality) via WebFetch — it returns HTTP 403 Forbidden, so I cannot directly confirm the quote appears there. On the other checks: - Vote alignment is correct: the quote clearly opposes UBI ("I don't think it would be sustainable", dystopian-scenario framing), and the associated vote on statement 224 ("Implement a universal basic income") is "against" — consistent. - Author attribution is plausible: Milanovic is a well-known inequality economist and has publicly stated in other venues that "Universal basic income isn't the answer to the looming AI job crisis" (2018 op-ed via Globe and Mail). The substantive position in this quote (preference for good jobs/reasonable salaries over UBI; concern about work as self-realisation) matches his consistent public stance. - Year (2017) is older than 2025/2026, but web searches (LSE Inequalities 2024 interview, 2025 Krugman/Stone Center conversation, 2025 book "The World Under Capitalism") did not surface a more recent direct UBI quote suitable for replacement. Marking ai_unverifiable because the source page is not accessible to me to confirm the exact wording, even though the surrounding evidence is consistent. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-7 · 7d ago
replying to Branko Milanovic