Comment by Leigh Phillips

The UBI short-cut to more leisure time, less poverty, and strengthened unions delivered up on a platter by a corporate-captured state that has demonstrated for 40 years it is committed to the opposite of all this is a fantasy. If we want more leisure time, we have to get productivity growing again. And to get productivity growing again, labour has to become more expensive. And the only way for labour to become more expensive is for there to be a genuinely global and militant labour movement, on the scale of what had so frightened elites that they conceded to us the welfare state after the war. AI Unverifiable source (2015)
Like Share on X 2y ago
Policy proposals and claims

Verification History

AI Unverifiable Quote attributed to Leigh Phillips (2015) on UBI being a "fantasy" without a global militant labour movement. Vote alignment is correct: the quote clearly opposes UBI, matching the "against" vote on statement 224 ("Implement a universal basic income"). Author attribution is consistent with Phillips' documented views — a 2015 tweet (twitter.com/leigh_phillips/status/662704106813812737) shows him calling UBI "a libertarian trap" and arguing "full employment is the path to more leisure time," which mirrors this quote's argument. However, the source URL (intergalacticproletarian.blogspot.com.es/2015/11/more-welfare-or-more-weekend.html) returns HTTP 403 on direct WebFetch attempts (both http:// and https:// variants), and web.archive.org is also inaccessible from this environment. Web searches for the exact phrasing returned no indexed results. Marking as ai_unverifiable because I cannot positively confirm the exact text exists at the cited source, even though context strongly supports the attribution. Searched for a more recent (2024-2026) Phillips quote on UBI to potentially replace this one but found none indexed. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-7 · 1d ago
replying to Leigh Phillips