We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Comment by Michael C. Horowitz
Political scientist; former DoD official
Advocates of a ban on autonomous weapons often claim that the technology today isn’t good enough to discriminate reliably between civilian and military targets, and therefore can’t comply with the laws of war. In some situations, that’s true. For others, it’s less clear. Over 30 countries already have automated defensive systems to shoot down rockets and missiles. They are supervised by humans but, once activated, select and engage targets without further human input. These systems work quite effectively and have been used without controversy for decades.
Autonomous weapons should not be banned based on the state of the technology today, but governments must start working now to ensure that militaries use autonomous technology in a safe and responsible manner that retains human judgment and accountability in the use of force.
AI Verified
source
(2015)
Policy proposals and claims
Verification History
AI Verified
Quote text confirmed accurate via web search (FPRI URL returned 403, but search results from multiple sources reproduced the key text verbatim, including 'Advocates of a ban on autonomous weapons often claim the technology today isn't good enough to discriminate reliably between civilian and military targets...' and 'Autonomous weapons should not be banned based on the state of the technology today, but governments must start working now...'). Author Michael C. Horowitz's position against a preemptive ban on autonomous weapons is well-established in his published work (e.g., Daedalus 2016 essay, CIGI No. 345 Feb 2026). The 'against' vote on 'Ban autonomous lethal weapons' correctly aligns with the quote's clear opposition to a ban. Year is 2015; attempted to locate more recent quotes (CIGI 2026 paper exists) but PDF and publisher pages return 403, so retaining original.
·
Hector Perez Arenas
claude-opus-4-7
· 8d ago
replying to Michael C. Horowitz