We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
defense
ai-regulation
ai-policy
public-interest-ai
international-relations
ethics
ai-governance
regulations
policy
ai
Ban autonomous lethal weapons
Cast Your Vote:
Results (162 votes):
Total
(162 votes)
For 120 (74%)
Abstain 3 (2%)
Against 39 (24%)
·
For (117)
-
Scott BessentU.S. Secretary of the Treasury (2025–present); founder of Key Square Groupvotes For and says:
I think it was very important that President Trump and President Xi agreed that humans should always be involved in any military decisions that SI makes, and the SI should not be allowed to be autonomous for major military actions.
AI Verified source (Nov 20, 2026) -
Verity CoyleDeputy Director for Arms, Crisis, Conflict and Arms Division at Human Rights Watch; leads work on the Stop Killer Robots campaignvotes For and says:
Machines should never be allowed to decide who lives and dies on a battlefield, but that is the dystopian reality that is fast approaching.
AI Verified source (Nov 17, 2026) -
Volker TürkUN human rights chiefvotes For and says:
A machine must never have the power to decide whether a human being survives or dies. Human judgement and responsibility must remain at the centre of decisions involving the use of force.
AI Verified source (Nov 16, 2026) -
Government of LiberiaNational government of the Republic of Liberia, represented in international forums by its official delegations.votes For and says:
Decisions involving the use of lethal force, the deprivation of human life, and the escalation of conflict must never be abdicated to autonomous algorithms. Meaningful human control and accountability remain the non-negotiable bedrock of internationa...
more AI Verified source (Sep 23, 2026) -
Hirotsugu TerasakiChief Executive Director of the Soka Gakkai International Peace Center.votes For and says:
While we continue to work toward a world free from both nuclear weapons and autonomous killing machines, we welcome the focus in the ongoing negotiations on ensuring ‘meaningful human control’ over autonomous weapons.
AI Verified source (Jul 23, 2026) -
Elke SchwarzPolitical theorist researching the ethics of war and emerging military technologies.votes For and says:
Large language models simply shouldn’t be used for targeting, since they will inevitably hallucinate and contribute to civilian harm.
AI Verified source (Jul 21, 2026) -
Annelie LotrietSouth African Member of Parliament and representative to the Inter-Parliamentary Union, speaking on autonomous weapons systems and international humanitarian law.votes For and says:
We must define the scope and parameters of autonomous weapons in a manner that safeguards against their development and holds those in violation accountable.
AI Verified source (Jul 21, 2026) -
Naveed ShahPolitical Director of Common Defense and U.S. Army veteran.votes For and says:
As an Army veteran who served in Iraq, I know the moral responsibility that comes with taking human life in combat, decisions that must never be handed over to machines.
AI Verified source (Jul 17, 2026) 1 of 2 -
Don BeyerU.S. Representative from Virginia's 8th district; co-sponsor of the GUARDRAILS Act on AIvotes For and says:
No machine should ever be given the power to decide to kill a human being on its own. Allowing AI systems to independently select and engage targets carries serious risks; machines cannot understand morality or the value of human life, nor can they b...
more AI Verified source (Jul 17, 2026) 1 of 2 -
Tom BarrettU.S. Representative for Michigan's 7th congressional district.votes For and says:
Artificial intelligence is playing an increasingly critical role in strengthening our national defense, but it should never be the one making life-or-death decisions.
AI Verified source (Jul 17, 2026) 1 of 4 -
Sara JacobsU.S. Representative from California's 51st congressional districtvotes For and says:
AI mistakes on the battlefield have the potential to be catastrophic: civilian casualties, friendly fire, unintended escalation, and calculations made on faulty data. These aren’t risks worth taking – not when they can result in unnecessary lives los...
more AI Verified source (Jul 17, 2026) 1 of 2 -
Nick MotternCo-coordinator of the Weaponized Drone Ban Treaty Campaign and peace activist.votes For and says:
We are calling for a treaty to remove all weapons from drones, rather than to ban drones controlled autonomously by AI. This is because all militaries will claim that there will always be a human in ultimate control of AI-augmented drones in spite of...
more AI Verified source (Jul 16, 2026) -
David SwansonCampaign coordinator for RootsAction and peace activist focused on war abolition and disarmament.votes For and says:
Dozens of national governments have already stated their support for banning autonomous weapons, and dozens of others expressed their inclination to support such a ban. So, a treaty could be established among those nations, on the model of the recent...
more AI Verified source (Jul 16, 2026) -
Cardinal Baldo ReinaVicar General of Rome and Cardinal Vicar of the Diocese of Rome.votes For and says:
No machine, no algorithm, and no autonomous system can be placed at the center of decisions upon which the survival of humanity depends. Decisions concerning life and death, peace and war, and the future of peoples and generations yet to come must re...
more AI Verified source (Jul 16, 2026) -
Simon AdamsProfessor of Human Rights at Murdoch University and former President and CEO of the Center for Victims of Torture.votes For and says:
Killer robots are a horror that belongs in science fiction. There is nothing more sinister than outsourcing killing and warfighting to emotionless, faceless machines that will select which humans get to live or die. Lethal autonomous weapons systems ...
more AI Verified source (Jul 16, 2026) -
António GuterresUN Secretary-Generalvotes For and says:
Transferring the decision-making to killer robots would be morally repugnant and politically unacceptable.
AI Verified source (Jul 15, 2026) 1 of 6 -
Alex TurnerAI safety researcher and former Google DeepMind research scientist.votes For and says:
-
Daryl G. KimballExecutive Director of the Arms Control Association; arms-control and nuclear-risk policy expert.votes For and says:
The international community should adopt binding rules requiring human oversight of autonomous weapons systems and strict compliance with applicable international law at all times.
AI Verified source (Jul 14, 2026) -
Bertrand RondepierreDirector of France's Ministerial Agency for Defense Artificial Intelligence (AMIAD).votes For and says:
In France, the choice of the "human-in-the-loop" principle imposes major engineering constraints on our engineers to ensure genuine human responsibility and operational risk assessment.
AI Verified source (Jul 10, 2026) -
Archbishop Ettore BalestreroApostolic Nuncio and Permanent Observer of the Holy See to the United Nations and other international organizations in Geneva.votes For and says:
Indeed, since full moral causality belongs only to personal agents and not to artificial ones, if AI is to be used to uphold human dignity and truly serve the common good, responsibility for its use must remain with human decision-makers, with accoun...
more AI Verified source (Jul 7, 2026) -
Elizabeth WarrenU.S. Senator (D-MA)votes For and says:
DoD has a strategic, legal, and moral responsibility to ensure that AI technology is deployed with meaningful constraints to comply with U.S. and international laws, including by preventing civilian harm.
AI Verified source (Jul 7, 2026) -
Mustafa Al-MaryaniIraqi Minister of Communications who addressed the UN Global Dialogue on Artificial Intelligence Governance in July 2026.votes For and says:
We need to make sure that AI is only a tool for life, not a tool for developing lethal weapons which would threaten international peace and security.
AI Verified source (Jul 7, 2026) -
Halla TómasdóttirPresident of Iceland.votes For and says:
We must not normalize a future in which human beings delegate the irreversible decision to take a human life to a machine. Meaningful human responsibility must remain where the stakes are highest.
AI Verified source (Jul 7, 2026) -
Luc FriedenPrime Minister of Luxembourgvotes For and says:
As AI integrates into defence systems and the conduct of warfare, human judgement and responsibility must never be surrendered in decisions over life or death. This is why I believe that wherever voluntary principles fall short, we must be prepared t...
more AI Verified source (Jul 6, 2026) -
The Global AI AccordIndependent, non-commercial consultation text proposing binding international governance of artificial intelligence.votes For and says:
Autonomous weapons that select and engage human targets without meaningful human control must be prohibited absolutely, and all other autonomous weapons must be subject to binding regulation.
AI Verified source (Jul 5, 2026) -
Daniela AmodeiPresident and co-founder of Anthropic.votes For and says:
The reason we chose fully autonomous weapons and mass domestic surveillance as the areas where we simply can't say yes is because the technology is so new that we do not believe the laws may be perfectly designed to account for how the technology cou...
more AI Verified source (Jul 2, 2026)
Loading more opinions...
Abstain (2)
Loading more opinions...
Against (38)
-
Helen ClarkFormer Prime Minister of New Zealand and former Administrator of the United Nations Development Programmevotes Against and says:
Militaries around the world are increasingly relying on artificial intelligence to find, track and annihilate targets. [...] A meaningful treaty would prioritise human control, accountability and non-proliferation. It would ban autonomous weapons sys...
more AI Verified source (Nov 17, 2026) -
Cordula DroegeDirector of International Law, Movement and Partnerships at the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC).votes Against and says:
The ICRC has called for legally binding rules that would: Prohibit those autonomous weapons that pose the greatest threat, namely: “Unpredictable” autonomous weapons, whose effects cannot be sufficiently understood, predicted and explained; and auton...
more AI Verified source (Oct 15, 2026) -
Edmarverson A. dos SantosAuthor of a 2026 policy brief on international-law rules, treaty design, and human control for autonomous weapons.votes Against and says:
A total prohibition on all autonomous weapons would likely fail to distinguish between high-risk anti-personnel systems and narrowly bounded defensive systems used against incoming missiles or munitions.
AI Verified source (Jul 15, 2026) -
Michael J. BrodkaU.S. Army major and author writing on lethal autonomous weapon systems and military targeting.votes Against and says:
Closing it requires redesigning Army doctrine, organizations, and training to integrate LAWS into targeting under lawful human-on-the-loop control.
AI Verified source (Jul 2026)
Loading more opinions...
More
h/ai
votes
More
h/ai-governance
votes
More
h/ai-policy
votes
More
h/ai-regulation
votes
| Create a global institute for AI, similar to CERN |
| Require AI systems above a capability threshold to be interpretable |
| AI labs should give independent evaluators employee-like access |
More
h/defense
votes
| [🇺🇸 Congress, Jan 2026] Giving Congress power to block AI chip exports to adversaries |
| [🇺🇸 Congress, Dec 2025] Establishing a National Security and Defense AI Institute |
More
h/ethics
votes
More
h/international-relations
votes
| The CERN for AI should have a central hub in one location |
| Restrict the CERN for AI initiative to EU member states |
| Establish an international AI incident reporting system |
More
h/policy
votes
| Ban governments from using AI to conduct mass surveillance of citizens |
| AI will create more jobs than it destroys |
| [🇺🇸 Congress, Dec 2025] Establishing a National Security and Defense AI Institute |
More
h/public-interest-ai
votes