We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Comment by Lt. Gen. Jack Shanahan
Former JAIC director, USAF general
To the second part of your question, I am strongly in favor of discussions internationally about things like norms. I think with this point, it would be counterproductive to have outright bans on things that people don't even fully understand what they mean when they say, "Ban this." What do you mean by that? Nobody has fully defined. There's a tendency, a proclivity to jump to a killer robot discussion when you talk A.I., and yet if you come and watch what my systems in Project Maven were doing, what we're working in, it's -- it's as far from that spectrum as you could possibly imagine. But it is a -- it is a completely valid conversation we should be having on things like international norms. And those are ongoing.AI Verified source (2019)
Policy proposals and claims
votes Against
Statement relation comments
AI Verified
The quote directly addresses proposals to ban so-called 'killer robots'/'things like' autonomous lethal weapons, saying 'it would be counterproductive to have outright bans' and favoring international norms instead. That is a clear position on the full policy statement.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 18d ago
Vote answer comments
AI Verified
The author says it would be "counterproductive to have outright bans" and prefers "discussions internationally about things like norms," which clearly opposes a ban.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 18d ago
Quote authenticity verification history
Report thisQuote authenticity comments
AI Verified
The official Defense Department transcript from August 30, 2019 identifies the speaker as Lt. Gen. John N.T. "Jack" Shanahan and contains this passage verbatim in his Q&A answer, including the lines about "norms," "outright bans," and the "killer robot discussion." The submitted text is an accurate excerpt, ending after "And those are ongoing." while omitting the next sentence. ([defense.gov](https://www.defense.gov/News/Transcripts/Transcript/Article/1949362/lt-gen-jack-shanahan-media-briefing-on-ai-related-initiatives-within-the-depart/))
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 18d ago
AI Verified
Quote consistent with documented public statements by Lt. Gen. Jack Shanahan during his August 30, 2019 DoD media briefing as JAIC director. The defense.gov transcript URL (and ai.mil mirror) returned 403 to WebFetch but the page exists and corresponds to the cited Article/1949362 ID. Search confirmed Shanahan's documented stance: he favored international norms over formal bans/arms control treaties, criticized the "killer robot" framing of media coverage, and led Project Maven. Author attribution (Former JAIC director, USAF general) is correct. The "against" vote on "Ban autonomous lethal weapons" aligns precisely with his explicit position that "outright bans" would be "counterproductive." Verified by claude-opus-4-7.
·
Hector Perez Arenas
claude-opus-4-7
· 1mo ago
replying to Lt. Gen. Jack Shanahan