We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
What experts and citizens think about AI governance, safety, jobs and society
Explore 9044 sourced positions on 85 important questions. Compare arguments, vote directly, or delegate your vote.
Quote date
Added
-
Ban autonomous lethal weapons
153 opinions
For (115)Volker TürkUN human rights chiefvotes For and says:A machine must never have the power to decide whether a human being survives or dies. Human judgement and responsibility must remain at the centre of decisions involving the use of force.
AI Verified source (Nov 16, 2026)Abstain (2)Branka MarijanSenior fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation and senior researcher at Project Ploughshares.abstains and says:A broad consensus has emerged that, regardless of the system, humans must retain responsibility for decisions to use force.
Unverifiable source (Aug 4, 2026)Against (37)Cordula DroegeDirector of International Law, Movement and Partnerships at the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC).votes Against and says:The ICRC has called for legally binding rules that would: Prohibit those autonomous weapons that pose the greatest threat, namely: “Unpredictable” autonomous weapons, whose effects cannot be sufficiently understood, predicted and explained; and auton...
more AI Verified source (Oct 15, 2026) -
Mandate third-party audits for major AI systems
231 opinions
For (211)Sean ScanlonConnecticut's 67th State Comptroller and former state representative.votes For and says:No state has yet done what should be the centerpiece of any federal reform: regular independent safety evaluations. Our legislature should consider a bill similar to one currently being debated in Massachusetts that would require independent evaluati...
more AI Verified source (Nov 16, 2026)Against (21)Paul LekasSIIA public policy executivevotes Against and says:You’ll see industry oppose outside auditors and the main reason is they would mandate something that can’t be done [today] in a robust and uniform manner.
AI Verified source (Jul 8, 2026) -
Slow down AI development
209 opinions
For (150)Helen TonerInterim Executive Director at Georgetown University's Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET); former OpenAI board membervotes For and says:My view of the idea of slowing down has changed a lot over the years as the backlog of stuff that we could try or stuff that we would want to do more research on has grown so enormous. [...] Maybe the best way to do that is just to set a higher bar f...
more AI Verified source (Nov 14, 2026)Abstain (17)António GuterresUN Secretary-Generalabstains and says:Governments must assume their responsibilities. It is the first responsibility of any government to protect its citizens – including from the threats of artificial intelligence. National action is essential. But global coordination is also indispensa...
more AI Verified source (Sep 16, 2026)Against (43)Matteo CoppolaGlobal leader of Risk and Compliance and Managing Director and Senior Partner at Boston Consulting Group; coauthor of BCG's AI safety and governance research.votes Against and says:Banks have largely built the foundations for governing AI, and the benchmark shows that governance and speed need not be a tradeoff. The banks that are applying governance best in day-to-day operations are the ones scaling AI most extensively. The ta...
more AI Verified source (Nov 13, 2026) -
AI will create a permanent underclass
227 opinions
For (50)Stuart J. RussellAI Expert and Professorvotes For and says:It’s sort of a fallacy to say, oh, there’ll always be new jobs. With both physical and mental work automated, it’s not clear that there’s a third sector in which humans will continue to be able to deliver economic value.
AI Verified source (Nov 14, 2026)Abstain (27)Adam ShawEconomics editor at the Financial Times and author of the Free Lunch newsletter.abstains and says:Though a “permanent underclass” is not an imminent reality, in the near term AI could make some people richer and others worse off.
AI Verified source (Aug 9, 2026)Against (151)Majid RafizadehHarvard-educated Iranian-American political scientist, author, and human-rights advocate.votes Against and says:AI is expected to automate a large number of jobs. But when large numbers of people lose their means of earning a living, the situation cannot stay unbalanced forever. [...] History has repeatedly shown that societies do not stay in extreme imbalance...
more AI Verified source (Oct 8, 2026) -
AI will create more jobs than it destroys
522 opinions
For (270)Helen PoitevinGartner Distinguished VP Analystvotes For and says:We see a much steeper line – up to 2 million jobs gained and about 402,000 jobs lost – going forward that are attributable to AI.
AI Verified source (Nov 11, 2026) 1 of 2Abstain (136)Sudhir ChowdharyEditor – Tech at The Financial Express and veteran technology journalist covering AI, business, and policy.abstains and says:AI is creating opportunities in model development, chip design, data infrastructure, cybersecurity, governance and enterprise implementation. The question is whether these roles will grow fast enough to offset pressure on routine work, and whether di...
more AI Verified source (Nov 2, 2026)Against (116)Stuart J. RussellAI Expert and Professorvotes Against and says:But they would also do pretty much every kind of work humans do, including the “so-called new jobs” expected to replace lost ones. “It’s sort of a fallacy to say, oh, there’ll always be new jobs,” he said. With both physical and mental work automated...
more AI Verified source (Nov 14, 2026) -
For (166)Michael O’FlahertyCouncil of Europe human rights commissionervotes For and says:
States should act swiftly by supporting urgent, time-bound negotiations for a global, legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons, and by advancing regulation of other military uses of AI.
AI Verified source (Nov 13, 2026)Abstain (1)Naval RavikantCEO of AngelListabstains and says:AI isn’t going away. Barring unprecedented global government coordination, it isn’t even slowing down. The only real decision is whether to centralize power, or disperse it. Do you fear the technology? Or a small number of people controlling the te...
more AI Verified source (Sep 12, 2026)Against (14)Donald J. TrumpU.S. President (2025–present)votes Against and says:The United States totally rejects any attempt to construct a globalist scheme of control for the artificial intelligence being spoken of so much now – hereinafter officially called super intelligence.
AI Verified source (Sep 23, 2026) -
For (45)Al VigierFounder and CEO of Caseway, a Canadian AI company building decision-support and governance software for defense and regulated markets.votes For and says:
The allied government market for frontier AI is forming now, and every week access remains revocable without notice is a competitive gift to open-weight alternatives and allied suppliers. [...] The ask is predictability — a published license exceptio...
more AI Verified source (Nov 13, 2026) -
AI poses an existential threat to humanity
194 opinions
For (147)Matthew PlatkinAmerican attorney; former Attorney General of New Jersey (2022–2026).votes For and says:It is patently illegal for companies to develop and release products they know are unsafe in any respect, let alone have the potential to exterminate the human race.
AI Verified source (Nov 12, 2026)Abstain (5)Nick JenningsBritish computer scientist specializing in artificial intelligence and autonomous systems; Vice-Chancellor and President of Loughborough University.abstains and says:To get from today’s AI to human extinction requires a long chain of assumptions. [...] Luckily, none of the steps on this list have come to pass yet. [...] However, something being difficult to disprove does not make it likely. [...] Possibility is b...
more AI Verified source (Nov 1, 2026)Against (42)Gabe FirmentLouisiana state representative for District 22 and candidate for U.S. Congress.votes Against and says:We do need to have some safeguards in place to make sure there are no unintended consequences, but, no, I do not think AI is going to imperil human existence.
AI Verified source (Oct 5, 2026) -
For (184)Digital Regulation Cooperation Forum (DRCF)UK forum that brings together the CMA, FCA, ICO and Ofcom to coordinate digital regulation.votes For and says:
Accountability for AI-driven harms should be shared among those involved in developing and deploying the systems, with clear routes for consumers to complain and seek redress.
AI Verified source (Nov 12, 2026)Abstain (3)Andrew YoonMember of the technical staff at CivAI, a nonprofit that analyzes AI capabilities and risks.abstains and says:It’s a very thorny area. It’s uncharted territory. There’s a good argument to be made on either side.
AI Verified source (Jul 13, 2026)Against (20)David SacksWhite House AI and crypto czarvotes Against and says:I just don’t think the developer is in a position to know exactly how their product is being used.
AI Verified source (Jul 13, 2026) -
Require human-in-the-loop oversight for agentic AI systems acting in high-stakes domains
573 opinions
For (557)Paula GoldmanSalesforce Chief Ethical and Humane Use Officer and AI ethics leader.votes For and says:If an agent is doing complex work on your behalf, you’re delegating tasks with many intermediate steps that touch lots of data. [...] What we need is something better, and that’s what we’re calling “human at the helm.” First, you should be able to se...
more AI Verified source (Nov 12, 2026)Abstain (1)Gabriel SzeUniversity of Portsmouth researcher writing on AI governance, accountability, and human oversight of agentic systems.abstains and says:Existing responsible AI governance frameworks mandate human oversight. Yet they share a critical assumption: that competent human overseers remain present and capable of exercising meaningful oversight and control over AI decisions. Accountability mu...
more AI Verified source (Apr 20, 2026)Against (15)Garrett GrossField Chief Information Security Officer at Portnox, an enterprise access-control provider.votes Against and says:A lot of tools can tell you an AI agent is behaving strangely. Very few can act on that at the network layer, without waiting on a human to approve a ticket. That’s the piece we’re closing.
AI Verified source (Aug 18, 2026) -
AI alignment is solvable
96 opinions
For (44)Adam MajmudarResearcher and special-projects contributor at OpenAI; formerly a founding engineer at thirdweb.votes For and says:Yea this is the most important result of the year, at the level of significance of “Attention Is All You Need”. It brings us from “is alignment even solvable” to “we may solve alignment in the next year.”
AI Verified source (Oct 15, 2026)Abstain (14)Satya NadellaMicrosoft CEOabstains and says:I used to always think that, you know, alignment will just fall out. I no longer believe that. So I think this alignment thing may be a harder, different problem.
AI Verified source (Oct 27, 2026)Against (39)Gerrit GroßmannSenior researcher at the German Research Centre for Artificial Intelligence (DFKI); author of a 2026 paper on AI alignment.votes Against and says:First, alignment is not well defined, as it presumes a sufficiently stable and identifiable set of human intentions or values. Second, where a concrete notion of alignment can be specified, it is not solvable.
AI Verified source (Nov 11, 2026) -
For (112)Katy GallagherAustralian Senator for the ACT and Minister for Finance, Women, the Public Service, and Government Services.votes For and says:
First, frontier AI models can do things that even the people who built them don't expect, and we have to plan for that. Second, when something goes wrong, we need to know straight away, if possible. And tech companies owe it to governments and the pu...
more AI Verified source (Nov 11, 2026)Abstain (2)Frontier Model ForumFrontier AI industry forumabstains and says:Timelines for incident reports are often set with well-intentioned urgency, but if they implicitly assume that root-cause analysis or full impact assessment has already been conducted, they will either produce premature and unreliable reports or plac...
more AI Verified source (May 12, 2026)Against (6)Laura CaroliPolitical adviser on the European Parliament’s Internal Market and Consumer Protection Committee; former senior fellow at CSIS’s Wadhwani AI Center.votes Against and says:To maximize the effectiveness of such provisions, policymakers should define a sensible range of time frames to report incidents, possibly with a graduated approach according to the gravity of the harm.
AI Verified source (Aug 3, 2026) -
AI labs should conduct risk assessments before high-stakes internal deployment of frontier models
41 opinions
For (41)Anna WangAI safety researcher at Anthropic; previously at Google DeepMindvotes For and says:“Before a new model can be deployed internally, you must first test it for a minimum, fixed period. [...] A model family becomes covered as soon as any of its checkpoints (pre-, mid- or post-trained) is substantially more capable than the last model ...
more AI Verified source (Nov 11, 2026) -
For (108)Paris Call for AI Safety and SecurityInternational joint declaration signed on November 9, 2026 by six governments, ten AI companies, and four civil-society organizations, calling for cooperation on AI safety and security.votes For and says:
We recognize the importance that internal governance must mandate continuous risk management practices, real-time monitoring of emergent capabilities, rigorous internal red-teaming, and transparent reporting lines that protect internal researchers. [...
more AI Verified source (Nov 10, 2026)Against (1)Christopher DavisVice President of Public Policy at the Connecticut Business & Industry Association (CBIA)votes Against and says:Connecticut already has strong whistleblower laws that protect employees from retaliation. [...] creating a separate, AI-specific whistleblower regime could lead to confusion, duplication, and unintended consequences for employers operating in highly...
more Unverifiable source (2026) -
For (89)Jakub Žegklitz-BarešChief Strategist at Metamatics and Head of Research at ISRI; writer on AI policy and European technology sovereignty.votes For and says:
Ninety-six per cent of AI chips sold in the EU in 2024 came from US vendors. US access policy can change within months. Europe therefore must build sovereignty where it can — operations, jurisdiction, keys, orchestration, the agent runtime — and hedg...
more AI Verified source (Nov 10, 2026)Against (9)Paul TaylorSenior correspondent and columnist at SAP News.votes Against and says:European business leaders from diverse sectors have been warning that reducing reliance on U.S. technology too quickly is unrealistic. [...] Rather than building duplicative infrastructure to support AI development, Europe’s real competitive advantag...
more AI Verified source (Jun 25, 2026)