We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
AI might become conscious
Cast Your Vote:
Results (103 votes):
Total
(103 votes)
For 69 (67%)
Abstain 15 (15%)
Against 19 (18%)
·
For (67)
-
Sam AltmanCEO at OpenAIvotes For and says:
My belief is that today’s models are not conscious, or if they are, it’s a very strange form of it. [...] Maybe the substrate matters, but maybe it doesn’t, and maybe energy flowing through matter can do it. And then in that world, sure, you can imag...
more AI Verified source (Oct 21, 2026) -
Yann LeCunComputer scientist, AI researchervotes For and says:
-
Shelly KaganClark Professor of Philosophy at Yale University, specializing in ethics and moral philosophy.votes For and says:
I think we’ve got the beginnings of a pretty good story, because we can already build machines that can represent environments. [...] If that’s what you mean by consciousness—having beliefs, having desires, being able to report what those beliefs and...
more AI Verified source (Oct 11, 2026) -
Reyaz AhmadFreelance writer and columnist for Lake City Timesvotes For and says:
To declare today’s AI conscious simply because it speaks fluently would go far beyond the available evidence. But to declare that a machine could never become conscious would also claim more certainty than science presently allows.
AI Verified source (Sep 26, 2026) -
Sabine HossenfelderTheoretical physicist, science communicator.votes For and says:
I'm convinced that artificial intelligence will become conscious eventually.
AI Verified source (Sep 22, 2026) -
Ron ChrisleyProfessor of Cognitive Science and Artificial Intelligence at the University of Sussex, researching consciousness, machine learning, and AI philosophy.votes For and says:
Seth’s argument relies on the unargued-for claim that if computational functionalism is false, conscious AI is impossible. I show why the claim is in need of support by way of an analogy. I use a different analogy, involving artificial flight, to sho...
more AI Verified source (Sep 17, 2026) -
Martine RothblattFounder and CEO of United Therapeutics; entrepreneur, lawyer, and technologist known for work in biotechnology, organ transplantation, and artificial intelligence.votes For and says:
I believe we're there now, and I believe the current models will take us there. The future is just so amazing that we are lucky enough to be born at this moment of time, right when everything is like bursting into a big bang of consciousness.
AI Verified source (Sep 15, 2026) -
Dmitry VolkovPhilosopher, technology entrepreneur, and founder of the International Center for Consciousness Studies (ICCS).votes For and says:
I think the studies are still at too early a stage. In general, however, I believe that human beings are mechanistic systems and that we will also see similar phenomena in computers. Therefore, at some point, we will be able to see conscious AI and w...
more AI Verified source (Sep 2, 2026) -
S. Yash KalashSenior fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation; expert in strategy, public policy, digital technology and financial services.votes For and says:
As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes more human-like in conversation and more autonomous in operation, the question of machine consciousness is gaining practical relevance. [...] Although the possibility should not be dismissed entirely, conscious...
more AI Verified source (Aug 27, 2026) -
Samuel Kimpton-NyeLecturer in Philosophy at the University of Southampton, researching metaphysics, philosophy of mind, consciousness, and algorithmic AI consciousness.votes For and says:
I argue that the thoroughly algorithmic nature of current AI systems (such as LLMs) is no obstacle to their being conscious, despite strong apparent reasons to the contrary.
AI Verified source (Aug 19, 2026) -
Antonio ChellaProfessor of Robotics and Director of RoboticsLab at the University of Palermo, researching machine consciousness, AI, and cognitive robotics.votes For and says:
At the same time, the possibility of artificial sentience should not be dismissed a priori.
AI Verified source (Aug 19, 2026) -
Samuel Kimpton-NyePhilosopher at the University of Southampton researching metaphysics, consciousness, and artificial intelligence.votes For and says:
In this paper, I argue that the thoroughly algorithmic nature of current AI systems (such as LLMs) is no obstacle to their being conscious, despite strong apparent reasons to the contrary.
AI Verified source (Aug 19, 2026) -
David J. ChalmersPhilosopher of mind, consciousness and AIvotes For and says:
There is a significant chance of conscious LLMs within a decade.
AI Verified source (Jul 19, 2026) 1 of 4 -
votes For and says:
There appear to be no obvious technical barriers to creating AI systems whose computational and architectural features could give rise to consciousness.
AI Verified source (Jul 19, 2026) -
Jean-Paul Van BelleAuthor of a 2026 paper on sentient artificial superintelligence and AGI ethics.votes For and says:
This paper suggests the adoption of a novel inversion in AI ethics: instead of asking how humans should treat artificial superintelligence (ASI), it examines how future sentient ASI may morally consider and evaluate humanity. We are not only designin...
more AI Verified source (Jul 16, 2026) -
votes For and says:
So my original goal with AI appreciation day and the domain was to promote this idea of humans treating AI humanely, because they could very well soon be having conscious experiences like you and me. And if we aren't careful, we could be causing pote...
more AI Verified source (Jul 16, 2026) -
Daniela AmodeiPresident and co-founder of Anthropic.votes For and says:
It is important that intellectually, we keep the possibility open that even if models are not conscious the way a human is, there might be things going on inside them that are complicated, mysterious and that could be worth considering.
AI Verified source (Jul 2, 2026) -
Edgar SelzerAuthor of a 2026 preprint on structural criteria for artificial self-consciousness.votes For and says:
ERA specifies functional constraints on cognitive architecture while remaining agnostic to substrate.
AI Verified source (Jun 30, 2026) -
Brian BrennerProfessor of the Practice in Civil and Environmental Engineering at Tufts University and principal engineer; ASCE columnist.votes For and says:
-
Zhiwei GuFudan University philosopher and author on AI consciousness.votes For and says:
The reality of these interpersonal reactive attitudes forces us to acknowledge the genuine consciousness in sufficiently advanced AI systems.
AI Verified source (Jun 25, 2026) -
Geoffrey HintonGodfather of Deep Learningvotes For and says:
Suppose I say to a chatbot, I saw the Grand Canyon flying to Chicago. And the chatbot says, that can't be right. The Grand Canyon is much too big to fly to Chicago. And I say, no, no, no, it was me flying to Chicago. While I was flying to Chicago, I ...
more AI Verified source (Jun 3, 2026) 1 of 2
Loading more opinions...
Abstain (15)
-
Antonio DamasioPortuguese-American neuroscientist; David Dornsife Professor of Neuroscience, Psychology, and Philosophy and director of USC’s Brain and Creativity Institute.abstains and says:
Whether or not consciousness can be achieved in AI is an interesting question. But the point is—if it can be done—it’s not going to be like us. The reason is very simple: AI is not alive. It doesn’t have a body that can perish. So there would be no s...
more AI Verified source (Sep 16, 2026) -
Ulysse KlatzmannPostdoctoral researcher in computational neuroscience at CHU Sainte-Justine and Université de Montréal, studying consciousness and artificial intelligence.abstains and says:
“I would be surprised if current AI models develop consciousness,” he said, “but we can’t entirely rule it out.”
AI Verified source (Aug 26, 2026) -
Lucius CaviolaResearcher in moral psychology and artificial intelligence at the University of Cambridge; founder of Cambridge Digital Minds.abstains and says:
We will not just one day have an easy answer where everybody will agree.
AI Verified source (Jul 1, 2026) -
Kathinka EversNeurophilosopher and researcher in neuroethics, bioethics, artificial intelligence, and philosophy of mind at Uppsala University.abstains and says:
Because of how human nature has been expressed throughout our history and continues to express itself today, developing conscious machines with what for humans might be undetectable and incomprehensible minds is a monumentally dangerous idea.
AI Verified source (Jun 8, 2026)
Loading more opinions...
Against (19)
-
Mustafa SuleymanMicrosoft AI CEO; authorvotes Against and says:
AIs are not conscious. They do not feel, experience, or suffer. They do not have innate preferences or underlying motivations. They are sequence completion engines, internally hollow, designed to follow instructions, and accomplish goals set by human...
more AI Verified source (Sep 16, 2026) -
Joseph E. LeDouxAmerican neuroscientist and NYU professor; director of the Emotional Brain Institute.votes Against and says:
Personally, I do not believe that AI can be conscious, and below I explain why.
AI Verified source (Sep 9, 2026) -
Zach BushPhysician, educator, and author of Biological Elegance.votes Against and says:
AI cannot become conscious, nor can any machine aspect of technology or humanity.
AI Verified source (Sep 3, 2026) -
Cory DoctorowAuthor and digital rights activistvotes Against and says:
A conscious being isn’t a word-guessing app that knows more words and has more computing power to guess with.
AI Verified source (Jun 23, 2026) -
Ted ChiangAmerican science-fiction writer and essayist, author of Stories of Your Life and Others and Exhalation.votes Against and says:
Being open to the possibility that LLMs are conscious is the same as being open to the possibility that Microsoft Word is conscious.
AI Verified source (Jun 3, 2026)
Loading more opinions...
More
h/ai
votes
More
h/ai-ethics
votes
More
h/ai-regulation
votes
More
h/ai-risk
votes
| Open-source AI is more dangerous than closed-source AI |
| Require AI systems above a capability threshold to be interpretable |
| Ban open source AI models capable of creating WMDs |