We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Require human-in-the-loop oversight for agentic AI systems acting in high-stakes domains
Cast Your Vote:
Results (580 votes):
Total
(580 votes)
For 564 (97%)
Abstain 1 (0%)
Against 15 (3%)
·
For (560)
-
Matt LetaCEO of Future Works; digital-transformation leader and author focused on enterprise AIvotes For and says:
The owner and whoever carries the risk (the controller for payments, the plant manager for a schedule change) agree in writing what the system decides alone and what it drafts for a person to approve. [...] Our agentic AI architecture guide sets the ...
more AI Verified source (Nov 22, 2026) -
International Committee of the Red CrossHumanitarian organizationvotes For and says:
For years, the ICRC and many others have urged states to ensure that humans retain control over the use of force and that life-and-death decisions are never handed over to machines.
AI Verified source (Nov 21, 2026) -
Paula GoldmanSalesforce Chief Ethical and Humane Use Officer and AI ethics leader.votes For and says:
If an agent is doing complex work on your behalf, you’re delegating tasks with many intermediate steps that touch lots of data. [...] What we need is something better, and that’s what we’re calling “human at the helm.” First, you should be able to se...
more AI Verified source (Nov 12, 2026) -
Priscilla ChongManaging Director, Singapore, at Amazon Web Services (AWS).votes For and says:
Even with these safeguards in place, a human must stay in the loop. This is especially important in financial services. [...] An agent helps you expand the surface of thinking; then a human (comes) in to make the decision.
AI Verified source (Nov 11, 2026) -
Umashankar LakshmipathyExecutive Vice President and Head of Cloud, Infrastructure and Security Services, EMEA at Infosys.votes For and says:
Human oversight remains important, but requiring approval for every action would undermine the efficiency that agentic AI is intended to deliver. It can also lead to approval fatigue, where reviews become routine and provide little meaningful protect...
more AI Verified source (Nov 9, 2026) -
Giovanni MartinezDatabase Support Engineer at Tiger Data, AWS Community Builder, and specialist in PostgreSQL, production reliability, and agent-assisted database operations.votes For and says:
AI agents can write migrations, but production changes need guardrails. This live demonstration walks through an agent-assisted PostgreSQL workflow using Tiger Cloud and the Tiger CLI: provisioning an isolated development service, generating versione...
more AI Verified source (Nov 7, 2026) -
Marcelo LorenzettiChief AI Officer and Principal AI Architect at Guild Systems, specializing in enterprise AI architecture, agentic AI governance, cloud infrastructure, and operational resilience.votes For and says:
As AI agents move from experimentation into production, they are increasingly capable of executing commands, accessing enterprise systems, modifying infrastructure, and making operational decisions without continuous human supervision. But what happe...
more AI Verified source (Nov 7, 2026) -
Rory BlundellFounder and CEO of Gravitee, an AI-agent management and API-security company.votes For and says:
Every AI agent should have a clear identity, role, and level of authority, along with oversight and recourse mechanisms. It’s imperative that every AI agent has a named human responsible for its actions. For enterprises to confidently trust AI agents...
more AI Verified source (Nov 6, 2026) -
David RomeoSenior Vice President of Innovation at Allata, leading enterprise AI platform and governance work.votes For and says:
For a contract analysis agent, harm is a missed liability clause that costs the company seven figures. [...] Human-in-the-loop review means defining, in advance, which decisions require human confirmation before execution. High-stakes, low-volume dec...
more AI Verified source (Nov 6, 2026) -
Eyal Ben EzraCo-founder and CEO of Willow, an enterprise AI-agent governance and access-control company.votes For and says:
High-impact agent actions should still require human approval when policy alone can’t capture the business impact.
AI Verified source (Nov 5, 2026) -
CapgeminiMultinational information technology services and consulting company.votes For and says:
That matters when AI influences a medical decision, controls a vehicle or robot, or supports a critical business judgment. Competence is essential. But so are predictability and honesty: does the system know what it knows, what it does not know and h...
more AI Verified source (Nov 5, 2026) -
LeidosAmerican technology company serving government and commercial customers with digital, engineering, and mission innovations.votes For and says:
As AI agents take on more responsibility and act with limited human involvement, organizations need to be able to set clear operating limits while keeping people in charge of critical decisions. [...] Set and enforce boundaries that determine which a...
more AI Verified source (Nov 4, 2026) -
Andrew BudFounder and CEO of iProov; technology entrepreneur, Chartered Engineer, and Fellow of the Royal Academy of Engineering specializing in biometric identity assurance.votes For and says:
For organizations to realize the full potential of agentic AI, they need to task agents with increasingly consequential responsibilities. But some actions must remain subject to human control, approval and accountability.
AI Verified source (Nov 4, 2026) -
Raluca CsernatoniCarnegie Europe fellow and Brussels School of Governance professor researching European security, defense, and emerging technologies including AI.votes For and says:
Cybersecurity and defense procurement should require rigorous legal and technical review throughout the development, lifecycle, and acquisition of agentic systems, alongside independent evaluations, incident reporting, and meaningful mechanisms for h...
more AI Verified source (Nov 3, 2026) -
Simon HuntChief Product Officer at Securonix; cybersecurity product leader with over 30 years of experience as a CTO, CPO, and GM.votes For and says:
“Okay, the AI SOC operator can operate within those parameters, but if it goes beyond them, it goes back to the human.” Having a human in the loop for every decision becomes having a human in the loop for exceptional decisions. [...] “I would, howeve...
more AI Verified source (Nov 3, 2026) -
Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (ADNOC)UAE state-owned energy company; developer and operator of AI-enabled energy infrastructure and industrial systems.votes For and says:
ADNOC today announced a landmark multi-year partnership with OpenAI and G42 at ADIPEC, becoming the first energy company to deploy OpenAI’s advanced artificial intelligence (AI) platform for connecting and coordination frontier AI agents across compl...
more AI Verified source (Nov 2, 2026) -
Adam IpsenPluralsight technology writer and ISC2 Certified in Cybersecurity, with AI cybersecurity and governance training and professional expertise in AI, cybersecurity, and software development.votes For and says:
What happens if the AI agent decides to delete or expose data, or message a customer under nobody’s authority? This can create compliance issues or loss of customer trust, because your organization had orphaned agents running autonomously that should...
more AI Verified source (Nov 2, 2026) -
Maureen Doyle-SpareIndependent researcher in AI governance and founder of Doyle-Spare Research, specializing in agentic AI governance.votes For and says:
On each in-scope decision, a runtime measurement, the Semantic Deviation Index quantifies how far the agent's resolved meaning sits from the authorized one. A Deterministic Gate turns that measurement into an enforced decision before execution author...
more AI Verified source (Oct 29, 2026) -
Sandhya ArunChief Technology Officer at Wipro, focused on enterprise AI and technology transformation.votes For and says:
Agentic systems therefore need clear triggers for human review and escalation. During solution design, leaders should define who owns each decision, what agents may and may not do, who can approve or override an action, how exceptions will be escalat...
more AI Verified source (Oct 29, 2026) -
Husham AhmedCounsellor at Pakistan’s Permanent Mission to the United Nations Office and other International Organizations in Geneva.votes For and says:
Without effective human judgement and control, these systems increase the risks of miscalculation and escalation, lower the threshold for the use of force, and erode compliance with international humanitarian law (IHL). The decision to employ nuclear...
more AI Verified source (Oct 25, 2026) -
Dipesh KauraCountry Director, India and SAARC at Securonix, a cybersecurity company.votes For and says:
As organisations introduce Agentic AI into security operations, human oversight should not be treated as an afterthought. Furthermore, AI should empower human expertise and not replace it. Agentic AI has to be designed with analysts at the center, en...
more AI Verified source (Oct 24, 2026) -
Shirin HamidChief Information Officer and Director of the Information Technology Department at the International Monetary Fund; digital-governance and emerging-technology leader.votes For and says:
The intelligent central bank is not the bank with the most AI, It is the bank whose AI can be trusted, and can ensure that any AI that touches the financial system is explainable, governed, secure, ethical, and human-supervised. [...] For every AI-in...
more AI Verified source (Oct 23, 2026) -
Carolyn DubyField CTO and Cybersecurity Lead at Cloudera; cybersecurity, data, and AI expert.votes For and says:
Organizations should evaluate consequential actions against the agent’s assigned task, the sensitivity of the data involved and the potential impact. Higher-risk activities, such as exporting confidential records or modifying production systems, shou...
more AI Verified source (Oct 22, 2026) -
Robin QiuPenn State Professor of Information Science and editor-in-chief of Digital Transformation and Society.votes For and says:
Human-in-Command (HIC) Governance: Complying with international regulatory demands for meaningful human monitoring, the strategic zenith of AI governance requires humans to act as architects rather than tactical micromanagers. Under the HIC model, op...
more AI Verified source (Oct 20, 2026) -
Sumit JoharChief Information Officer at BlackLine; enterprise cloud, cybersecurity, automation, and AI executive.votes For and says:
AI should not independently handle decisions where accuracy is essential in heavily regulated fields such as finance.
AI Verified source (Oct 19, 2026) -
iTechGuides TeamEditorial team at iTechGuides, a technology software directory and guide publisher.votes For and says:
Require fresh human approval before an irreversible or high-impact action, then log the identity, request, policy decision, approval, and resulting change in a system the agent cannot alter.
AI Verified source (Oct 18, 2026) -
Jaydeep SinghGeneral Manager for India at Kaspersky, with over 25 years of enterprise technology and cybersecurity experience.votes For and says:
Every AI agent should have its own identity and access to only what it needs. [...] High-impact or irreversible actions should require human approval.
AI Verified source (Oct 17, 2026) -
John M. BremenManaging Director, Board Advisor, and Chief Innovation & Acceleration Officer at WTW; contributor on AI governance and board oversight.votes For and says:
As agentic AI moves from generating content to making decisions and taking action, boards and C-suite leaders are looking beyond “human in the loop” as their AI oversight model. [...] The newer models don't eliminate the loop. It still belongs in hig...
more AI Verified source (Oct 16, 2026) -
Kapil TiwariAssociate Director and Product Management Lead for Hybrid Cloud Services at HCLTech, writing on AI-enabled cyber resilience and governed autonomy.votes For and says:
The future model is policy-governed autonomy: AI detects, prioritizes and executes approved low-risk actions at machine speed, while accountable leaders retain control of decisions with material operational, legal, regulatory or reputational conseque...
more AI Verified source (Oct 16, 2026) -
Satya NadellaMicrosoft CEOvotes For and says:
That same kind of mechanistic understanding eludes us in today’s Super Intelligence systems, even as the frontier models powering these systems are now more capable than traditional software systems. We can’t attribute model behaviors and outputs to ...
more AI Verified source (Oct 12, 2026)
Loading more opinions...
Abstain (1)
Loading more opinions...
Against (15)
Loading more opinions...
More
h/ai-governance
votes
More
h/ai-regulation
votes
More
h/ai-safety
votes
| Ban superintelligence development until safety consensus is reached |
| Ban open source AI models capable of creating WMDs |
| Require large datacenters to install kill switches for AI containment |
More
h/ethics
votes
| Mandate the CERN for AI to build safe superintelligence |
| Ban AI companion chatbots for minors under 18 |
| Ban AI impersonation of real individuals without their consent |
More
h/policy
votes
| The EU should build sovereign AI infrastructure to reduce dependence on US providers |
| We should adopt AI 2040 Plan A |
| Mandate 72-hour reporting of critical AI safety incidents to a national authority |