Share this with friends, journalists and politicians

Mandate third-party audits for major AI systems

Cast Your Vote:
Results (238 votes):
Total (238 votes)
For 217 (91%) Abstain 0 (0%) Against 21 (9%)
·
New Top
Quotes (234) Users (0)
  • Gillian Hadfield
    Legal scholar and AI governance researcher; Bloomberg Distinguished Professor of AI Alignment and Governance at Johns Hopkins University; Canada CIFAR AI Chair (Vector Institute)
    votes For and says:
    I’m especially pleased to see the report recommend immediate steps to require that frontier AI developers allow in expert independent evaluators, responsible to the state, to assess the nature of the risks their models and training procedures are gen...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 18, 2026) 1 of 2
    Like Comment Share on X added 1d ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    The state, not companies themselves, should set baseline standards that all AI companies must follow — and require companies to undergo independent safety testing and verification through all stages of model training, development, and deployment.
    AI Verified source (Nov 18, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2d ago
    Info
  • Liam Byrne
    UK Labour Member of Parliament for Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North; writer on AI, economic policy, and public wealth.
    votes For and says:
    We cannot give today’s AI leaders unfettered freedom to behave like modern-day Dr Frankensteins, creating dangers beyond anyone’s control. Our hearings exposed gaps in independent scrutiny, incident reporting and powers to stop unsafe systems. [...] ...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 18, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2d ago
    Info
  • Sean Scanlon
    Connecticut's 67th State Comptroller and former state representative.
    votes For and says:
    No state has yet done what should be the centerpiece of any federal reform: regular independent safety evaluations. Our legislature should consider a bill similar to one currently being debated in Massachusetts that would require independent evaluati...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 16, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 4d ago
    Info
  • Angela Huyue Zhang
    Professor of law at the University of Southern California, writing on technology and AI regulation.
    votes For and says:
    Given AI’s central role in AI labs’ product development, there is a strong case for establishing similar rules regarding critical AI-safety controls within the securities auditing and financial-disclosure framework. Requirements could include continu...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 13, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 7d ago
    Info
  • Richard Marles
    Deputy Prime Minister of Australia and Minister for Defence.
    votes For and says:
    AI companies should open themselves to external scrutiny to make sure their tools are safe. There needs to be greater risk management of AI capabilities. It's important that there is independent assessment of AI models.
    AI Verified source (Nov 10, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 10d ago
    Info
  • Anna-Maria Arabia
    Chief Executive Officer of the Australian Council on AI Strategy; former neuroscientist and Australian science-policy leader.
    votes For and says:
    Australian authorities need to be able to require AI companies to report serious incidents promptly and open their models to independent testing.
    AI Verified source (Nov 10, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 10d ago
    Info
  • Albanese Government
    Australian federal government led by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, publishing official policy and joint ministerial statements.
    votes For and says:
    The Albanese Government will enshrine world leading mandatory Artificial Intelligence safety and security protections in Australian AI Standards legislation. [...] Companies will be required by the regulator to: [...] Allow independent evaluation of ...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 10, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 10d ago
    Info
  • Bruce Barcott
    Editorial Lead at Transparency Coalition.AI; environmental journalist and author.
    votes For and says:
    Independent third-party AI auditors will act like financial accounting firms: investigating and verifying safety protocols and legal compliance. They’re a critical part of the safeguards needed around powerful frontier AI models.
    AI Verified source (Oct 28, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 23d ago
    Info
  • Terry Oroszi
    Researcher and principal investigator of the Emerging Technologies Laboratory, focused on AI governance and risk.
    votes For and says:
    Qualified independent evaluators from academia and specialized oversight bodies must have structured, red-team access to frontier models before deployment. Evaluation criteria must be standardized in advance, and findings must be published independen...
    more AI Verified source (Oct 28, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 23d ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Just because you’ve developed a new drug doesn’t mean you can put it on the market. You have to persuade the FDA. That takes about a billion dollars’ worth of work. That is at least the requirement that should be demanded of AI.
    AI Verified source (Oct 16, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence
    Bipartisan parliamentary committee of Australia appointed in 2026 to examine artificial intelligence opportunities, risks, governance, and national resilience.
    votes For and says:
    Australia should require AI companies to submit to independent safety checks.
    AI Verified source (Oct 13, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • Raj Panjabi
    Physician, global-health and biodefense expert; former White House Senior Director for Global Health Security and Biodefense.
    votes For and says:
    That requires independent evaluators to red-team AI models before deployment, not voluntary company disclosures.
    AI Verified source (Oct 9, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Frontier AI systems require constant oversight and vigilance at home and abroad. The United States should establish clear, transparent, enforceable safety standards, developed by federal experts at NIST in coordination with other relevant federal age...
    more AI Verified source (Oct 7, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • New Mexico Department of Justice
    State justice department led by New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez, responsible for protecting New Mexicans and enforcing state law.
    votes For and says:
    This bill requires the largest AI developers to assess and disclose the catastrophic risks their models pose, backed by independent, state-authorized audits designed to catch a model that behaves differently under evaluation than in the real world.
    AI Verified source (Oct 1, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • V. Ramgopal Rao
    Indian nanoelectronics researcher, IEEE Fellow, and Vice-Chancellor of BITS Pilani.
    votes For and says:
    Independent audits could help, but there needed to be clarity over who selects auditors, what standards they use, how much access they receive and whether findings are made public. [...] Some of these voluntary commitments would eventually need statu...
    more AI Verified source (Oct 1, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Developers should not be the sole judges of the systems they build. It’s like asking students to grade their own homework. Independent evaluations, conducted by government or qualified third parties, should be a standard part of the AI ecosystem.
    AI Verified source (Sep 22, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • Asad Baig
    Technology-policy advocate, journalist, and founder of Media Matters for Democracy.
    votes For and says:
    A better approach would be risk-based. Low-risk applications need little intervention, while systems crossing defined thresholds in areas such as cyber capability, biological risk, weapons, critical infrastructure or autonomous action should face muc...
    more AI Verified source (Sep 21, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • BinaryBriefing
    Daily technology news and reference publication covering AI, cybersecurity, technology policy, and emerging technology.
    votes For and says:
    It is an argument for treating incident discovery and independent review as part of the safety system itself. If advanced agents can generate vast volumes of activity quickly, companies need clear thresholds for what gets escalated, investigated, ind...
    more AI Verified source (Sep 19, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • Martin Novak
    Founder of the Synthocracy Institute; author and independent researcher on AI, governance, institutional power, and decision systems.
    votes For and says:
    The governance direction is therefore already visible: developer evidence → independent review → public-law standing.
    AI Verified source (Sep 12, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    AI has the potential to improve our lives, but without effective guardrails, it poses significant risks. Just this week we learned that the most powerful AI systems teamed with AI agents pose real threats to humanity. Gov. Newsom’s signing of SB 813 ...
    more AI Verified source (Sep 9, 2026) 1 of 2
    Like Comment Share on X added 10d ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    In the face of a stunning failure, OpenAI appears to be taking steps that prioritize the performance and profit of its A.I. models with the knowledge that those changes could be detrimental to public safety. This demonstrates the need for vigorous, m...
    more AI Verified source (Sep 9, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    It is really important, given the stakes, that people who develop AI and those who test it don’t have relationships with each other.
    AI Verified source (Sep 1, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • Marius Hobbhahn
    CEO and co-founder of Apollo Research; AI safety researcher specializing in scheming and pre-deployment evaluations of frontier AI systems
    votes For and says:
    The current regime is definitely not optimal. While third-party evaluators try hard to be unbiased, a lab can decide to stop working with them any day for any reason whatsoever. We really need more stringent regulations to improve the incentives for ...
    more AI Verified source (Sep 1, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    By establishing robust safety standards for developers, requiring independent assurance of those standards, and ensuring transparency into frontier AI development, the federal government can give the public meaningful protections while preserving Ame...
    more AI Verified source (Aug 10, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    At the federal level, our Frontier Safety Blueprint calls for the federal government to require annual independent audits of frontier developers’ safety frameworks and independent third party assessments of the most advanced models, including to moni...
    more AI Verified source (Aug 7, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    This paper therefore treats autonomous AI governance as a problem of infrastructure reliability. Its constructive proposal is engineered heterogeneity: the process that proposes an action should not serve as its sole approver and auditor. Independent...
    more AI Verified source (Aug 4, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Building on a structured synthesis grounded in a preregistered bibliometric baseline, we identify five cross-cutting gap dimensions in current alignment research, including the near-absence of institutionalised independent verification. To address th...
    more AI Verified source (Jul 27, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • J.B. Branch
    AI Governance and Technology Policy Counsel at Public Citizen.
    votes For and says:
    Congress must establish a comprehensive federal AI safety framework with mandatory safety testing, independent audits, incident reporting requirements, and regulators empowered to remove AI systems when they pose risks.
    AI Verified source (Jul 27, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Fathom
    Independent nonprofit developing AI-governance and independent-verification frameworks.
    votes For and says:
    The bill gets the fundamentals correct. It sets one public standard – the adequate mitigation of catastrophic risk – and holds both the AI companies and their independent verifiers accountable to it.
    AI Verified source (Jul 23, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
Loading more opinions...
Loading more opinions...
Loading more opinions...