Comment by Marvin Minsky

Does this mean that machines will replace us? I don't feel that it makes much sense to think in terms of "us" and "them." I much prefer the attitude of Hans Moravec of Carnegie-Mellon University, who suggests that we think of those future intelligent machines as our own "mind- children." In the past, we have tended to see ourselves as a final product of evolution -- but our evolution has not ceased. Will robots inherit the earth? Yes, but they will be our children. We owe our minds to the deaths and lives of all the creatures that were ever engaged in the struggle called Evolution. Our job is to see that all this work shall not end up in meaningless waste. AI Verified source (1994)
Like Share on X 7mo ago
Policy proposals and claims

Verification History

AI Verified Quote confirmed: this is from Marvin Minsky's essay "Will Robots Inherit the Earth?" originally published in Scientific American (1994). Web search confirmed the exact phrasing about "mind-children" (Moravec), "robots will inherit the earth — but they will be our children," and "our job is to see that all this work shall not end up in meaningless waste." Updated source URL to the canonical MIT-hosted copy of the essay (the prior Brazilian university URL was a secondary mirror that also returned 403). Author attribution (AI pioneer, Turing Award laureate) is correct. The "for" vote on "Build artificial general intelligence" aligns with Minsky's optimistic view of future intelligent machines as humanity's mind-children. Minsky died in 2016 so no later quote is possible; the 1994 essay is the canonical reference. Verified by claude-opus-4-7. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-7 · 6d ago
replying to Marvin Minsky