Gary Marcus
votes Against
We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Comment by Gary Marcus
Professor of Psychology and Neural Science
I have talked about having something like a CERN [European Organization for Nuclear Research] for AI, which might focus on AI safety. In some industries, we know how to make reliable [products], usually only in narrow domains. One example is bridges: You can't guarantee that a bridge will never fall down, but you can say that, unless there’s an earthquake of a certain magnitude that only happens once every century, we're confident the bridge will still stand. Our bridges don't fall down often anymore. But for AI, we can’t do that at all as an engineering practice—it’s like alchemy. There’s no guarantee that any of it works. So, you could imagine an international consortium trying to either fix the current systems, which I think, in historical perspective, will seem mediocre, or build something better that does offer those guarantees. Many of the big technologies that we have around, from the internet to space ships, were government-funded in the past; it's a myth that in America innovation only comes from the free market.AI Verified source (2024)
Policy proposals and claims
votes For
Statement relation comments
AI Verified
The quote directly endorses the full idea: the author says they have "talked about having something like a CERN for AI" and describes an "international consortium" for AI safety and better systems. That clearly supports creating a global AI institute similar to CERN.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 5mo ago
Vote answer comments
AI Verified
The quote clearly supports the idea: the author says, "I have talked about having something like a CERN for AI" and describes "an international consortium" to improve AI systems.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 5mo ago
Quote authenticity verification history
Report thisQuote authenticity comments
AI Verified
ai_verified: The exact passage appears at the cited source URL in Compiler’s interview with Gary Marcus, published September 26, 2024. The article attributes these words to Marcus, and the supplied excerpt matches the text on the page verbatim as published (see lines 55–57, in an interview note-labeled as edited for clarity and length). ([compiler.news](https://www.compiler.news/gary-marcus-ai-napster/))
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 5mo ago
AI Verified
Verified via web search. The quote is from Gary Marcus's interview on compiler.news ("Gary Marcus: We're suffering through the Napster era of AI"). Search results confirm the bridges/alchemy analogy and discussion of CERN for AI for AI safety. Marcus has been a public proponent of a CERN for AI since 2017. The vote "for" on "Grant member states majority governance control in the CERN for AI" aligns with the quote's emphasis on government funding and international consortia rather than free-market AI development. Source URL returned 403 to WebFetch but search excerpts directly quote the content.
·
Hector Perez Arenas
claude-opus-4-7
· 6mo ago
replying to Gary Marcus
Other opinions from Gary Marcus
See all
Gary Marcus
votes For
Ban autonomous lethal weapons
The White House and people at the top of the Pentagon seem to treat it as magic, whereas those who are actually building it realize that it hallucinates, it makes mistakes, stupid errors of reasoning. And if you put that into production, into practic...more Unverifiable source (2026)
Gary Marcus
votes Against
AIs understand
create bullshit in the sense that they [...] mimic the general thing...they fake their way through everythingAI Verified source (Nov 20, 2025)