We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Comment by Mateo Alaluf
Sociologist. Université libre de Bruxelles.
To replace a social security system primarily financed by contributions and based on wage solidarity with a rent paid by the Government and financed by tax income seems a war machine against the welfare state. In addition, an income provided unconditionally to anybody can only be mediocre and cannot ensure the financial independence of the beneficiaries. These would be obliged to accept to work for whatever wage in order to round up their benefits. As a result, there would be a degradation of the labour market and a proliferation of badly paid jobsAI Verified source (2016)
2y ago
Policy proposals and claims
votes Against
Statement relation comments
AI Verified
The quote directly discusses an unconditional income for everybody, funded by tax income and replacing parts of social security, and argues against its effects on welfare and labor markets. That is clearly about implementing a universal basic income as a whole.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 19d ago
Vote answer comments
AI Verified
The quote calls an unconditional income "a war machine against the welfare state" and says it would lead to "degradation of the labour market," clearly opposing a universal basic income.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 19d ago
votes Against
Statement relation comments
AI Verified
The quote clearly opposes unconditional income paid to everyone, arguing it would weaken the welfare state and worsen labor conditions. That implies opposition to a global dividend for every person, even though it does not discuss AI labs or equity funding specifically.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 18d ago
Vote answer comments
AI Unverifiable
The quote criticizes replacing social security with "a rent paid by the Government" and says "an income provided unconditionally to anybody" would harm the welfare state and labor market, but it does not specifically address AI labs, equity contributions, or a global trust.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 18d ago
votes Against
Statement relation comments
AI Verified
The quote clearly opposes a universal, unconditional government-paid income financed by tax revenue, calling it a threat to the welfare state and harmful to workers. A citizens' dividend funded from AI windfall profits is a specific version of that kind of policy, so the author’s opposition to the complete statement is clearly implied.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 18d ago
Vote answer comments
AI Verified
The quote clearly criticizes "a rent paid by the Government and financed by tax income" and says "an income provided unconditionally to anybody" would harm the welfare state and labour market, which opposes a citizens' dividend funded from taxed AI windfall profits.
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 18d ago
Quote authenticity verification history
Report thisQuote authenticity comments
AI Verified
ai_verified. A reliable reprint on solidaritéS says it is publishing extracts from Alaluf’s RTBF article and gives the French original at lines 84–86, including “machine de guerre contre l’Etat social” and “prolifération de « boulots » mal payés,” which matches the supplied English as a faithful translation and attributes it to Mateo Alaluf. An independent reprint in Ensemble! carries the same wording. One correction: the RTBF piece is cited elsewhere as dated 14 June 2013, so the quote appears authentic but the year is 2013, not 2016. ([solidarites.ch](https://solidarites.ch/journal/237-2/lallocation-universelle-contre-la-protection-sociale/))
·
YouCongress
gpt-5.4-2026-03-05
· 19d ago
AI Verified
Verified via web search. Mateo Alaluf is a sociologist at Université libre de Bruxelles who is a known critic of universal basic income. He authored the RTBF opinion piece "L'allocation universelle contre la protection sociale" (June 2013) at the provided source URL, and co-authored the book "Contre l'allocation universelle" (Lux Éditeur). The quote is a faithful English translation of his French arguments — notably the phrase "une machine de guerre contre l'État social" (war machine against the welfare state) and his arguments about degradation of the labour market. The vote direction "against" on "Implement a universal basic income" correctly reflects his position. Source URL confirmed to exist via web search results matching the article title and content, though the domain (rtbf.be) was blocked from direct fetch.
·
Hector Perez Arenas
claude-opus-4-6
· 3mo ago
replying to Mateo Alaluf