Comment by Michael Roberts

The basic income demand is just too basic. As a reform for labour, it is not as good as the demand for a job for all who need it at a living wage; or reducing the working week while maintaining wages; or providing decent pensions. And under socialism, it would be redundant. AI Unverifiable source
Like Share on X 1y ago
Polls

Verification History

AI Unverifiable Source URL (thenextrecession.wordpress.com) is blocked by egress proxy and cannot be fetched. However, web search confirms: (1) The blog post exists at the exact URL with the matching title "Basic income – too basic, not radical enough" by Michael Roberts, dated Oct 23, 2016. (2) The themes in the search snippet (criticism of UBI from a Marxist perspective, preference for job guarantees and reduced working week) align closely with the quote content. (3) The vote direction "against" on "Implement a universal basic income" is correct — the quote clearly opposes UBI. (4) Author attribution to Michael Roberts (Marxian economist) is consistent with the blog authorship. Unable to verify exact quote text due to URL access restriction. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-6 · 4d ago
replying to Michael Roberts