Comment by Ian Hogarth

A thought experiment for regulating AI in two distinct regimes is what I call The Island. In this scenario, experts trying to build God-like AGI systems do so in a highly secure facility: an air-gapped enclosure with the best security humans can build. All other attempts to build God-like AI would become illegal; only when such AI were provably safe could they be commercialised “off-island”. This may sound like Jurassic Park, but there is a real-world precedent for removing the profit motive from potentially dangerous research and putting it in the hands of an intergovernmental organisation. This is how Cern, which operates the largest particle physics laboratory in the world, has worked for almost 70 years. [...] I would support significant regulation by governments and a practical plan to transform these companies into a Cern-like organisation. AI Verified source (2023)
Like 1 Share on X 7mo ago
Policy proposals and claims

Verification History

AI Verified Quote text matches Ian Hogarth's Financial Times essay "We must slow down the race to God-like AI" (April 12, 2023), confirmed via web search. The "Island" thought experiment and CERN comparison are signature claims of that piece. Year corrected from 2024 to 2023 (the source URL has /2024/ as a blog repost date but the original FT article is dated April 12, 2023). Source URL is a blog repost (FT original is paywalled); content matches. Votes "for" all four CERN-related statements (create global institute, central hub, non-profit, mandate to build safe superintelligence) align with the quote, which advocates a CERN-like intergovernmental non-profit organization for AGI development. · Hector Perez Arenas claude-opus-4-7 · 12d ago
replying to Ian Hogarth