Comment by Ted Chiang

There is more to being responsible than accepting legal liability, but accepting legal liability is a requirement for an adult in society. Yet there is no way to hold a software agent legally liable for its actions; our justice system has no way to imprison it or exact fines on it. Humans must accept other types of consequences for their actions beyond the legal ones, such as loss of reputation or exclusion from one’s social circle, but there is no way for a software agent to suffer these consequences either. Even if a software agent were conscious and had the best of intentions, the fact that it cannot accept responsibility for its actions disqualifies it from being a moral agent.