We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Ban predictive policing
Cast Your Vote:
Results (54 votes):
Total
(54 votes)
For 40 (74%)
Abstain 0 (0%)
Against 14 (26%)
·
For (38)
-
AnthropicAI safety research companyvotes For and says:
Claude cannot be used to decide or recommend who to investigate, arrest, or charge in a law enforcement or criminal justice process.
AI Verified source (Oct 8, 2026) -
Wendy O’BrienUNODC Technology and Innovation Advisor and crime-prevention and criminal-justice officer focused on human-rights-based AI governance.votes For and says:
Noting concerns regarding the possibility of feedback loops, and the self-fulfilling prophecy of directing police attention to specific areas or individuals on the basis of historical data that may perpetuate patterns of over-policing, Member States ...
more AI Verified source (Sep 30, 2026) -
Laguna Beach City CouncilElected legislative body of Laguna Beach, California.votes For and says:
The City, and those acting on its behalf, shall not use AI systems for the following purposes: … Predictive policing that targets, scores, or profiles specific individuals.
AI Verified source (Sep 22, 2026) -
Alternative Federal Budget Working GroupCollective author of the Canadian Alternative Federal Budget’s 2026–27 artificial-intelligence policy chapter.votes For and says:
The act will employ the precautionary principle to prohibit the introduction of AI tools into high-risk settings, such as education, health care or the delivery of public services, unless there is clear evidence that they will not cause harm. Where h...
more AI Verified source (Sep 16, 2026) -
Mark DownsSixth Ward councilor, Morgantown City Council.votes For and says:
-
Safety Not SurveillanceUK coalition of grassroots and civil-society organisations campaigning against harmful technology and AI uses in policing and immigration.votes For and says:
We are calling for an end to so-called “predictive” policing technologies, and for legislation which protects people’s rights and safeguards against the harms of AI and tech uses in policing and immigration settings.
AI Verified source (Aug 25, 2026) -
European CommissionEU's executive bodyvotes For and says:
All AI systems considered a clear threat to the safety, livelihoods and rights of people are banned. The AI Act prohibits individual criminal offence risk assessment or prediction.
AI Verified source (Aug 3, 2026) -
Council of the European UnionEU Council of governmentsvotes For and says:
AI systems that pose a threat to people’s safety, rights or livelihoods are banned from use in the EU. These include cognitive behavioural manipulation, predictive policing, emotion recognition in the workplace and educational institutions, and socia...
more AI Verified source (Jun 29, 2026) -
Béatrice Fresko-RolfoMember of Monaco’s National Council and delegate to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe.votes For and says:
In the wrong hands, [AI] becomes a tool for mass surveillance, predictive policing, risk rating, social scoring, and even the censorship of political opinions. AI, however, does not confine itself to merely watching; it is therefore up to us to set l...
more AI Verified source (Jun 24, 2026) -
Alexander LauferTechnology and human-rights researcher at Amnesty International Netherlands.votes For and says:
It is impossible to design an objective or neutral risk profiling algorithm. Data about people is never objective. When governments use past social data to predict who is going to commit a crime such as fraud, they inevitably target individuals who b...
more AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026) -
Amnesty InternationalHuman rights NGOvotes For and says:
Risk profiling in migration, social security fraud detection and crime control must be banned. Predictive profiling and risk assessment systems, whether data driven or rules-based, should be banned in high stakes contexts even when humans make the fi...
more AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026) -
Baroness UddinIndependent member of the UK House of Lords; co-chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Digital Identity.votes For and says:
Indeed, AI profiling of Black and Asian men in the criminal justice system continues to replicate centuries-old bias.
AI Verified source (Jun 5, 2026) -
Ad Hoc Latino Leaders GroupStatewide cross-sector coalition of Latino leaders advancing community-rooted California policy priorities.votes For and says:
Prohibit predictive policing technologies and restrict surveillance tools such as license plate readers and facial recognition systems.
AI Verified source (Apr 29, 2026) -
David NolanSenior investigative researcher at Amnesty International, focused on human-rights concerns in policing technology.votes For and says:
The establishment and provision of data-driven law enforcement and predictive policing technologies by companies such as Palantir […] raises severe human rights concerns, particularly given such companies have a history of blatant contempt for human ...
more AI Verified source (Apr 28, 2026) -
ERGO NetworkEuropean network of Roma and pro-Roma grassroots organisations advocating for Roma equality, inclusion, and anti-discrimination policy.votes For and says:
Certain uses of AI should be prohibited altogether. Predictive policing systems that profile individuals or neighbourhoods, as well as biometric mass surveillance in public spaces, are fundamentally incompatible with the principle of non-discriminati...
more AI Verified source (Apr 2026) -
Mariano delli SantiLegal and Policy Officer at Open Rights Groupvotes For and says:
bias and stereotypes at scale. Black people, migrant people, poor people, people from geographic areas which have been historically over policed are more likely to be identified as at risk of committing a crime. [...] Predictive policing is a dangero...
more AI Verified source (Mar 17, 2026) -
Center for AI and Digital Policy (CAIDP)Digital rights NGOvotes For and says:
Prohibit predictive policing systems that undermine human rights, dignity, and due process.
AI Verified source (Mar 5, 2026) -
Center for the Study of Organized HateNonprofit, nonpartisan think tank researching organized hate and developing policy solutions on digital harms and extremism.votes For and says:
Prohibit the use of predictive policing and the use of biometric and facial recognition systems for mass surveillance.
AI Verified source (Feb 11, 2026) -
David DavisUK Conservative Member of Parliamentvotes For and says:
"The use of these sorts of predictive policing algorithms creates a postcode lottery of justice, reinforcing existing biases and inequalities. Infusing those systems with AI will only exacerbate the injustice," he warned.
AI Verified source (Jan 20, 2026)
Loading more opinions...
Abstain (0)
Loading more opinions...
Against (14)
-
Marc SchuilenburgProfessor of Digital Surveillance at Erasmus School of Law; researcher on AI, algorithms, ethics, and public safety.votes Against and says:
The lesson is not that predictive technology should be definitively banned at neighbourhood level, as advocated by the human rights organisation Amnesty International.
AI Verified source (Oct 6, 2026) -
Nigeria Police ForceNational police service of Nigeria, represented by its inspector general at the 2026 UN Chiefs of Police Summit.votes Against and says:
Artificial intelligence, digital forensics, and geospatial intelligence are transforming how we anticipate threats and conduct investigations.
AI Verified source (Jul 8, 2026) -
Jordan Public Security DirectorateJordan's national public-security authority, represented by its director at the 2026 UN Chiefs of Police Summit.votes Against and says:
That is why we believe that this summit is a strategic step allowing us to redefine the role of UN Police and strengthen its ability to respond to the ever-rapid changes by implementing a modern police system based on institutional complementarity, i...
more AI Verified source (Jul 8, 2026) -
Government of Solomon IslandsNational government of Solomon Islands, represented by its deputy police commissioner at the 2026 UN Chiefs of Police Summit.votes Against and says:
With artificial intelligence, digital technology, and the use of predictive tools, this can strengthen situational awareness, support evidence-based decision-making, and improve early warning and threat assessment.
AI Verified source (Jul 8, 2026) -
Naveen JoshiFounder and CEO of Allerin, writing on artificial intelligence, analytics, and responsible technology.votes Against and says:
Predictive policing falls into that same category. The goal isn’t to replace police work, it’s to make it more strategic.
AI Verified source (Jun 28, 2026) -
Government of the United KingdomUnited Kingdom central governmentvotes Against and says:
Officers across England and Wales will spend less time behind desks and more time protecting their communities, as the government today launches PoliceAI – a new national centre dedicated to the responsible development, piloting and scaling of artifi...
more AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026) -
Sarah JonesUK Crime and Policing Minister and Member of Parliament.votes Against and says:
AI is already helping police catch dangerous offenders, speed up investigations and keep our communities safe – and we are only just getting started.
AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026) -
Neil BasuFormer head of Counter Terrorism Policing in the United Kingdom.votes Against and says:
There is a lot of concern about AI but the truth is it is here, and it’s here to stay. AI can, if used correctly, be a force for good that will help policing become not just more efficient but far more effective. That means greater safety and securit...
more AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026) -
Ryan WainSenior Director of Policy & Politics at the Tony Blair Institute, commenting on technology and public policy.votes Against and says:
This is a welcome step to help police make better use of technology in the fight against crime. For too long, some of the loudest voices have focused on the risks of innovation without giving equal attention to the opportunities it offers to protect ...
more AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026) -
Ben JarvisChief Technology Officer for Data & AI at Telefónica Tech, writing on governed AI use in policing.votes Against and says:
Predictive policing shows how crime analytics can already help forces move from reactive response to earlier intervention, using existing data within governed environments.
AI Verified source (Mar 9, 2026) -
Stan KaranasiosProfessor in Information Systems at the University of Queensland, researching AI use in policing.votes Against and says:
Ultimately, whether AI technology improves policing outcomes depends on the governance surrounding it. Ensuring there is a vigilant human in every AI loop should be a non-negotiable safeguard.
AI Verified source (Mar 3, 2026)
Loading more opinions...
More
h/ai-governance
votes
| AIs understand |
| Mandate the CERN for AI to build safe superintelligence |
| Slow down AI development |
More
h/ai-regulation
votes
| AI labs should give independent evaluators employee-like access |
| Create a global institute for AI, similar to CERN |
| Democracies should coordinate export controls on AI chips to China |
More
h/data-privacy
votes
More
h/ethics
votes
More
h/law
votes
| Ban AI impersonation of real individuals without their consent |
| Ban the use of AI for mass surveillance |
| Grant developers the right to interoperate with large platforms without permission |
More
h/policy
votes
More
h/privacy
votes