Share this with friends, journalists and politicians

Guessing probabilities helps us communicate what we believe

Cast Your Vote:
Results (12 votes):
Total (12 votes)
For 10 (83%) Abstain 1 (8%) Against 1 (8%)
·
New Top
Quotes (12) Users (0)
  • European University Institute
    European postgraduate and postdoctoral teaching and research institute
    votes For and says:
    Bayesian probability provides a natural and intuitive framework for characterising and communicating uncertainty. Bayesian analysis simply applies the laws of probability to evaluate which hypothesis is more plausible in light of whatever relevant in...
    more Unverified source (Jan 14, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 4mo ago
    Info
  • Tasha Fairfield
    Professor at the European University Institute working on Bayesian methods and uncertainty communication
    votes For and says:
    Bayesian probability provides a natural and intuitive framework for characterising and communicating uncertainty. Bayesian analysis simply applies the laws of probability to evaluate which hypothesis is more plausible in light of whatever relevant in...
    more Unverified source (Jan 14, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 4mo ago
    Info
  • Tom Chivers
    Journalist and author of Everything is Predictable, writing on Bayes and forecasting
    votes For and says:
    On the Rootclaim thing: My impression was that they were doing Bayes badly. I have to admit I got a bit bogged down in the incredibly long article about it and all the back-and-forth, but as I understood it they really felt that you could come up wit...
    more Unverified source (May 8, 2024)
    Like Comment Share on X added 4mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    It's an idea dating back centuries that you could put probabilities on your lack of knowledge, essentially your ignorance. It's a number that expresses, you know, what we don't know.
    Unverified source (Dec 12, 2022)
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info
  • Annie Duke
    Decision strategist, author, and former professional poker player
    votes For and says:
    When we're expressing our opinions, and our beliefs, and our predictions to other people we take a stab at letting them know how certain we are. [...] On a scale of zero to 10 how sure are you of your belief? [...] what's your percentage on that?
    Unverified source (Mar 2018)
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    It can be meaningful to talk in terms of your beliefs being probabilities. [...] you can cash out those subjective probabilities in terms of the odds at which you would be willing to bet.
    Unverified source (Apr 8, 2016)
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    You want a rule that incentivizes people to report their true probabilities. [...] How do you want to align the incentives for expressing confidence?
    Unverified source (Aug 24, 2015)
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Communicating such predictions requires unambiguous events and numeric probabilities. [...] a miscommunication that was revealed once their beliefs were made explicit.
    Unverified source (2011)
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info
  • Michael A. Stoto
    Statistician, epidemiologist, and Georgetown University professor emeritus
    votes For and says:
    The language of subjective probability can and should be used to convey a clear and precise message to policymakers about the degree of uncertainty in a statistical estimate.
    Unverified source (Dec 1988)
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    When we say “such and such is unlikely” we mean that the chances of its NOT happening are in our judgment about three to one.
    Unverified source (1964)
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info
  • abstains and says:
    I think my real p(doom|no pause) is probably a few points above 20%, and my real p(doom|maybe-pause) is probably a few points below 20%, but the haters and losers get mad if you offer excessively specific probabilities like 18%, so I'm rounding both ...
    more Unverified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 5mo ago
    Info
  • David Aldous
    Probability theorist and professor emeritus of statistics
    votes Against and says:
    When someone states a 99.9% chance in the 2012 election example, adding “but that's just my degree of belief”, the additional comment doesn't add anything: they are really thinking qualitatively and making up a number to represent “very very likely”.
    Unverified source
    Like Comment Share on X added 8min ago
    Info