Share this with friends, journalists and politicians

Guessing probabilities helps us communicate our beliefs

Cast Your Vote:
Results (64 votes):
Total (64 votes)
For 56 (88%) Abstain 1 (2%) Against 7 (11%)
·
New Top
Quotes (62) Users (0)
  • votes For and says:
    Our forecasters apply expertise and local knowledge to assess these outcomes, then communicate the result as a forecast. [...] Rainfall forecasts are probabilistic. This means they provide a possible range of rainfall totals [...] and then the chance...
    more AI Verified source (May 21, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    People talk about probabilities all the time in cases where you don’t do infinite numbers of trials. [...] You’re not imagining doing that hundreds of times or an infinite number of times, you are expressing your personal degree of belief. That’s the...
    more AI Verified source (Apr 6, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 58min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Most previous discussions on expressing probabilities in forecasts started from an assumption that they can be hard for people to understand. [...] People can understand probabilistic forecasts and could indeed find it more useful to have the range o...
    more AI Verified source (Feb 3, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • European University Institute
    European postgraduate and postdoctoral teaching and research institute
    votes For and says:
    Bayesian probability provides a natural and intuitive framework for characterising and communicating uncertainty. Bayesian analysis simply applies the laws of probability to evaluate which hypothesis is more plausible in light of whatever relevant in...
    more AI Verified source (Jan 14, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 4mo ago
    Info
  • Tasha Fairfield
    Professor at the European University Institute working on Bayesian methods and uncertainty communication
    votes For and says:
    Bayesian probability provides a natural and intuitive framework for characterising and communicating uncertainty. Bayesian analysis simply applies the laws of probability to evaluate which hypothesis is more plausible in light of whatever relevant in...
    more AI Verified source (Jan 14, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 4mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Two metrics are used to communicate the degree of certainty in key findings: confidence and likelihood. Confidence [...] is based on the robustness of evidence and the degree of agreement, and is expressed qualitatively based on expert judgement. Lik...
    more AI Verified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    I think my real p(doom|no pause) is probably a few points above 20%, and my real p(doom|maybe-pause) is probably a few points below 20%, but the haters and losers get mad if you offer excessively specific probabilities like 18%, so I'm rounding both ...
    more AI Verified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 5mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    One of the most powerful tools in our arsenal is ensemble forecasting, a method that helps us understand and communicate the range of possible weather outcomes, and the confidence we have in our predictions. [...] To make ensemble information more ac...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 12, 2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    We will always communicate what doubt remains in our key analytical judgements to our customers [...] We use this standard set of language in probabilistic judgements to describe our assessed likelihood that a statement is true or that an event will ...
    more AI Verified source (Mar 24, 2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Forecast users [...] look to NOAA to regularly characterize and convey forecast confidence and uncertainty. [...] All prediction is inherently uncertain and effective communication of this uncertainty [...] benefits users’ decisions. [...] NOAA commu...
    more AI Verified source (2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • Robert F. Nau
    Decision scientist and Duke University professor emeritus
    votes For and says:
    You could discuss your opinions in informal, unscientific terms [...] but you can try to communicate with each other more precisely by directly or indirectly assigning subjective probabilities [...] One way is to make direct intuitive judgments of yo...
    more AI Verified source (2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    I think it’s really useful. It’s an extremely clear way to communicate: “I think there’s a 20% chance this will happen” is just way more informative than “I think it probably won’t happen,” which could be 0% to 50% or something. [...] I think it also...
    more AI Verified source (Aug 22, 2024)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
  • Tom Chivers
    Journalist and author of Everything is Predictable, writing on Bayes and forecasting
    votes For and says:
    On the Rootclaim thing: My impression was that they were doing Bayes badly. I have to admit I got a bit bogged down in the incredibly long article about it and all the back-and-forth, but as I understood it they really felt that you could come up wit...
    more AI Verified source (May 8, 2024)
    Like Comment Share on X added 4mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    My subjective judgements about probability are fuzzy, but still convey information. [...] Encouraging people not to use numerical probabilities only harms good-faith dialog by making it harder for people to clearly communicate their beliefs. [...] As...
    more AI Verified source (Dec 10, 2023)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1h ago
    Info
  • John May
    Strategist and writer on organizational belief systems
    votes For and says:
    When these opinions are expressed as beliefs, we use a syntax that might sound like this: ‘We believe that <this thing> will happen, to <this degree>.’ When people collaborate and debate these opinions, they can work towards a shared understanding. [...
    more AI Verified source (Dec 1, 2023)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • Misty C. Duke
    Researcher on intelligence analysis, probability, and confidence
    votes For and says:
    Intelligence agencies communicate uncertainty to decision-makers through verbal probability phrases that correspond to numerical ranges (i.e., probability lexicons) and ordinal levels of confidence. [...] The results demonstrated that providing the n...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 27, 2023)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    We want to communicate our degree of epistemic uncertainty [...] We can do the same thing, somewhat more quantitatively, by guessing how resilient our guesses are. [...] With either, one preserves precision, and communicates a better sense of uncerta...
    more AI Verified source (Nov 10, 2023)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Analytic products should indicate and explain the basis for the uncertainties associated with major analytic judgments, specifically the likelihood of occurrence of an event or development, and the analyst’s confidence in the basis for this judgment....
    more AI Verified source (Dec 21, 2022)
    Like Comment Share on X added 58min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Saying the probability of rain in Canberra tomorrow is between 0.5 and 0.7 [...] helps to indicate your level of uncertainty to other people. [...] it does potentially indicate something technical, which is how quickly you would update your beliefs a...
    more AI Verified source (Oct 28, 2022)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
  • Thomas Holtgraves
    Social psychologist researching language and uncertainty communication
    votes For and says:
    If we’re communicating our beliefs about something that’s uncertain, so it’s communicating uncertainty, right? [...] There’s all sorts of words [...] probability terms. [...] Other studies that we’ve done [...] we ask them to convey uncertainty. [......
    more AI Verified source (2022)
    Like Comment Share on X added 58min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    An outcome that has “a 70% chance” of occurring signifies a stronger expectation than an outcome that is merely “possible”. [...] Words, and perhaps also numbers, are rarely completely neutral but might contain clues to speakers’ beliefs, concerns, a...
    more AI Verified source (2022)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    The “Bayesian mindset” refers to explicitly writing down your best-guess probabilities and/or values [...] I've used the term “Bayesian mindset” to invoke Bayesian epistemology—in particular, the idea that all beliefs can be expressed as probabilitie...
    more AI Verified source (Dec 21, 2021)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Two calibrated approaches are used to communicate the degree of certainty in key findings, which are based on author teams’ evaluations of underlying scientific understanding. Confidence is [...] based on the robustness of evidence and the degree of ...
    more AI Verified source (2021)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Risk communication includes content conveyed numerically (for example probabilities, frequencies) [...] Uncertainty [is] a function of the lack of information and differences in certainty between individuals that reflect differences in personal exper...
    more AI Verified source (2021)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Assessments of subjective probability [...] reflect personal convictions rather than objective truths. [...] It is always possible to form and communicate that insight in clear and structured ways. [...] There is no situation in which foreign policy ...
    more AI Verified source (2019)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    Credences should be understood as beliefs in probabilistic contents [...] When you have high credence that Jones smokes, you believe a probabilistic content, you can assert it, and your audience can come to believe it. [...] The way we communicate ou...
    more AI Verified source (2019)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    The Bayesian representation of beliefs by probability measures is the centre-piece of an apparatus central in decision theory, statistics, decision analysis and uncertainty communication. [...] The language of probabilities is one that, in principle,...
    more AI Verified source (2019)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2h ago
    Info
Loading more opinions...
Loading more opinions...
  • votes Against and says:
    One of the biggest dangers in communicating analytic judgements is presenting subjective assessments with unwarranted precision. [...] For most intelligence assessments, qualitative language communicates uncertainty more honestly than arbitrary numer...
    more AI Verified source (Jul 8, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • Pavel Slutskiy
    Communication theorist and Chulalongkorn University associate professor
    votes Against and says:
    When we receive information, we do not process it in a probabilistic manner in terms of uncertainty reduction. That is simply not how the human mind works. [...] This perspective aligns with our intuitive understanding of how humans truly communicate...
    more AI Verified source (2024)
    Like Comment Share on X added 59min ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    The probability calculus expresses beliefs numerically by a probability function. For a statement A, P(A) is an agent’s degree of belief in A. [...] Assigning a credence to these outcomes is [...] unhelpful for communicating with other agents. [...] ...
    more AI Verified source (Mar 25, 2019)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1h ago
    Info
Loading more opinions...