We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
ai-ethics
open-source
policy
research-policy
ai-governance
regulations
ai-safety
open-science
ai-regulation
transparency
Require open source AI models to include safety benchmarks in release notes
Cast Your Vote:
Results (48 votes):
Total
(48 votes)
For 39 (81%)
Abstain 0 (0%)
Against 9 (19%)
·
For (39)
-
Kanupriya YakhmiPhD student at the University of the Cumberlands and author on AI safety documentation and governance.votes For and says:
The way to get there is a shared machine-readable format. I call it a Safety Framework Card.
AI Verified source (Jul 24, 2026) -
Thinking MachinesAI model developer whose Inkling model card reports pre-release safety evaluations and benchmarks.votes For and says:
Inkling reports reasoning, agentic, factuality, chat, vision, audio, and safety benchmark results at effort=0.99.
AI Verified source (Jul 14, 2026) -
Rebecca FinlayCEO of Partnership on AI.votes For and says:
Now we need to open that with more open benchmarks, verification, independent testing, making sure that models reflect linguistic diversity, open science, and technical standards.
AI Verified source (Jul 7, 2026) -
Independent International Scientific Panel on Artificial IntelligenceUnited Nations independent scientific panel that issued its July 2026 preliminary report on artificial intelligence.votes For and says:
Researchers also consistently advocate for rigorous measurement and evaluation protocols to assess a model’s safety prior to publication. International bodies like the United Nations can play a critical role in coordinating global standards, ensuring...
more AI Verified source (Jul 2026) -
Google DeepMindAI research company.votes For and says:
DiffusionGemma underwent careful scrutiny, input data pre-processing, and post-training evaluations as reported in this card to help mitigate the risk of these biases.
AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026) -
AnthropicAI safety research companyvotes For and says:
Developers should test their models against each of the four Enumerated Risk categories and publish a summary of the results.
AI Verified source (Jun 2026) -
Hoki KimProfessor at Chung-Ang University researching AI governance and open-weight foundation-model policy.votes For and says:
The model card is restructured from prose README into a machine-readable structured document organized around three principles: (1) heritage transparency — full disclosure of training data, base model, and alignment lineage; (2) alignment provenance ...
more AI Verified source (May 7, 2026) -
Wojciech ZarembaHead of AI Resilience at the OpenAI Foundation; OpenAI co-founder.votes For and says:
As these tools become part of everyday life, it's important that they're designed to be safe, trustworthy, and appropriate for different stages of development. That's why independent evaluation and public accountability matter.
AI Verified source (May 5, 2026) -
Vivek MurthyFormer U.S. Surgeon General (19th and 21st); physician and public health advocatevotes For and says:
We urgently need policies and institutions that will demand transparency, allow for independent safety evaluations, and enforce accountability. The well-being of the next generation is at stake.
AI Verified source (May 5, 2026) -
Ellen PackCo-CEO of Common Sense Media.votes For and says:
The Youth AI Safety Institute's role is to set a high bar: rigorous standards, independent testing, and transparent results that raise the bar for everyone.
AI Verified source (May 5, 2026) -
Common Sense MediaKids media and tech nonprofitvotes For and says:
It will establish safety standards, build open-source evaluations that AI developers can run against their models, independently test AI products, and publish the results to provide transparency and accountability.
AI Verified source (May 5, 2026) -
Helen TonerInterim Executive Director at Georgetown University's Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET); former OpenAI board membervotes For and says:
Results of testing for AI models’ capabilities and risks. A lack of clear, up-to-date information about what the world’s best AI systems are capable of puts the U.S. government at a huge disadvantage in understanding how the AI frontier is progressin...
more AI Verified source (Apr 22, 2026) -
Liam RomanisIndependent cybersecurity and AI security consultant; author of a draft model-card security standard.votes For and says:
This standard applies to any machine learning model published to a public model repository with a downloadable model card or README. [...] MCSS-1 (Baseline) | Any publicly published model | All HuggingFace models, open-source releases [...] Safety ev...
more AI Verified source (Apr 20, 2026) -
Marisol VegaWriter on AI governance and dual-use risks from open-weight model releases.votes For and says:
A more tractable near-term proposal is mandatory pre-release evaluation against a defined set of uplift benchmarks, particularly for chemical and biological capability, with results published before weights ship.
AI Verified source (Feb 19, 2026) -
Frontier Model ForumFrontier AI industry forumvotes For and says:
Develop and publish monitorability evaluations. Standardized evaluations and metrics can improve assessments for how monitorable an AI model’s reasoning process is. These tests would measure the clarity, coherence, and faithfulness of a model’s Chain...
more AI Verified source (Jan 27, 2026) -
OpenAIAI research organizationvotes For and says:
In the US, we support state efforts to align around common frameworks such as California SB 53, the New York RAISE Act, and Illinois SB 315, which emphasize transparency, public reporting around catastrophic-risk evaluations and safety incidents, whi...
more AI Verified source (2026) -
Centre for Future GenerationsEuropean think tank on emerging technologiesvotes For and says:
Policy and safeguards must evolve just as swiftly [...] requiring safety assurances for powerful open releases before the window for meaningful intervention closes.
AI Verified source (2026) -
Huzaifa SidhpurwalaRed Hat security engineervotes For and says:
In November 2024, we authored a paper addressing the rapidly evolving ecosystem of publicly available AI models and their potential implications for security and safety. In this paper we proposed standardization of model cards and extensions to inclu...
more AI Verified source (Sep 3, 2025) -
Vincent CaldeiraCTO of Red Hat in APACvotes For and says:
Class III (Open Model): The entry point for openness. This involves the partial release of components which typically includes the model architecture, final model weights, and basic documentation, like a technical report, evaluation results, a model ...
more AI Verified source (Jul 15, 2025) -
Julia SmakmanLegal researcher, Ada Lovelace Institutevotes For and says:
platforms that host libraries of open-source AI models to ensure that models are uploaded with appropriate system and safety information
AI Verified source (2025) 1 of 2 -
Cheryl SeahDirector, Drew & Napier LLCvotes For and says:
Select models where [...] performance on evaluation and red-teaming efforts are disclosed, over models that don’t – model cards can help with providing this information;
AI Verified source (Nov 2024) -
Jack TitusAI policy writer at FASvotes For and says:
For models with risk above the lowest level, most evaluation results and methods should be public, including any performed mitigations.
AI Verified source (Mar 5, 2024) -
David Evan HarrisUC Berkeley public scholar, tech policy advisorvotes For and says:
Unsecured “open-source” AI systems pose a massive series of threats [...]. They deserve no exemptions and should be regulated just like other high-risk AI systems.
AI Verified source (Dec 4, 2023) -
Professor John McDermidProfessor of safety-critical systemsvotes For and says:
policymakers and regulators have no choice but to deal with both open and closed-source models. [...] If independent testing were done and results on an intelligible scale were published, I think that would encourage constructive competition.
AI Verified source (Nov 8, 2023) -
Irene SolaimanHugging Face chief policy officer, researchervotes For and says:
For pre-deployment risk assessments for open source, [...] models, [...] are released with a model card. Model cards [...] will generally come with a set of evaluations.
AI Verified source (Nov 8, 2023)
Loading more opinions...
Abstain (0)
Loading more opinions...
Against (8)
-
Mark ZuckerbergMeta CEO; Facebook co-foundervotes Against and says:
-
Arthur MenschMistral AI co-founder and CEOvotes Against and says:
So I don't see any risk associated with open sourcing models. I only see benefits.
AI Verified source (Aug 4, 2024) -
Anjney Midhaa16z general partnervotes Against and says:
Open source is the heart of software innovation and this bill slows it down. [...] There should be zero liability at the model layer.
AI Verified source (Jun 19, 2024) -
MetaSocial media and AI companyvotes Against and says:
Until consensus develops, it is premature to require specific measurements and benchmarks.
AI Verified source (Mar 26, 2024) -
Andrew NgBaidu; Stanford CS faculty; founded Coursera and Google Brainvotes Against and says:
However, it is important to differentiate regulating applications (which we need) vs. regulating the technology (which is ill-advised).
AI Verified source (Dec 11, 2023)
Loading more opinions...
More
h/ai-ethics
votes
More
h/ai-governance
votes
| Create a global institute for AI, similar to CERN |
| AI agents should be granted legal personhood as non-human corporations |
| Require large datacenters to install kill switches for AI containment |
More
h/ai-regulation
votes
More
h/ai-safety
votes
More
h/open-science
votes
| The CERN for AI should be completely non-profit |
| Require frontier AI labs to conduct nearly all R&D publicly but keep the weights closed |
More
h/open-source
votes
More
h/policy
votes
| The CERN for AI should be completely non-profit |
| AI agents should be granted legal personhood as non-human corporations |
| AGI could make governments subordinate to the companies that develop it |
More
h/regulations
votes
More
h/research-policy
votes
| Slow down AI development |
| COVID-19 originated from a lab-related incident rather than natural zoonotic spillover |
| Bayesian analysis is the right framework for settling the COVID-19 origins question |