Share this with friends, journalists and politicians

Require frontier AI labs to conduct nearly all R&D publicly but keep the weights closed

Cast Your Vote:
Results (48 votes):
Total (48 votes)
For 6 (13%) Abstain 0 (0%) Against 42 (88%)
·
New Top
Quotes (48) Users (0)
  • UK AI Security Institute
    United Kingdom government institute for evaluating advanced AI systems.
    votes For and says:
    Open-weight systems are the lifeblood of open research and innovation in AI. They increase transparency, allow for widespread red teaming, and decrease market concentration. However, open-weight models also pose unique risks. They can allow harmful A...
    more AI Verified source (Aug 25, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    It’s very dangerous to make this a dichotomy between complete openness all the way to complete closedness. In complex software systems as well as scientific systems it’s much more nuanced.
    AI Verified source (Aug 12, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Thomas Larsen
    AI Futures Project researcher writing on Plan A assumptions, AI governance, and AI safety strategy.
    votes For and says:
    Proposal #1: Total Research Transparency. Nearly all AI research is fully transparent to the public, including AI algorithms, code, and documentation, for all frontier AI projects. AI model weights, significant fractions of the training data, and a s...
    more AI Verified source (Jul 13, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 1mo ago
    Info
  • votes For and says:
    AI companies should be transparent about everything but the model weights, so outside groups can check the AI company's homework.
    AI Verified source (Jul 9, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • AI Futures Project
    Nonprofit AI forecasting research group behind AI 2027 and Plan A; led by Daniel Kokotajlo.
    votes For and says:
    Plan A is not that crazy, but it’s close: the algorithms are mandated to be open source, and while the weights aren’t (in fact the weights are banned from being OS), access to the weights is mandated to be open; members of the public can do evaluatio...
    more AI Verified source (Jul 9, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
Loading more opinions...
Loading more opinions...
  • Karthik Tadepalli
    Research Scholar at the Centre for the Governance of AI, studying the economic effects of transformative AI; PhD in Economics from UC Berkeley.
    votes Against and says:
    Internal model transparency is a minimum viable form of research transparency: instead of sharing every innovation, labs share only the finished artifact – the model itself. And while AI 2040 argues for this transparency to be total, to all members o...
    more AI Verified source (Sep 1, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • Andrew Ng
    Baidu; Stanford CS faculty; founded Coursera and Google Brain
    votes Against and says:
    If I were to try to give one prescription, it would be to promote openness, because AI is amazing technology and I want it to be in everyone’s hands.
    AI Verified source (Aug 12, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    Open source is a positive and important force for empowering people and preventing centralization that is detrimental for both safety and the economy. Meta continues to be strongly supportive of open source, including open source AI models. The curre...
    more AI Verified source (Aug 10, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    We are extremely interested in looking at ways to build U.S. open source, make it competitive, make it the preferential adoption by planet Earth,
    AI Verified source (Aug 5, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • James Landay
    Denning Director of Stanford’s Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (Stanford HAI).
    votes Against and says:
    Open weights are progress. You can download the model, run it on your own machine, keep it out of someone else’s data pipeline. But you still can’t see how the thing was built, what it was trained on, or why it behaves the way it does. That’s not an ...
    more AI Verified source (Aug 4, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • The Linux Foundation
    Nonprofit consortium supporting open-source technology ecosystems
    votes Against and says:
    As policymakers and regulators work through questions of AI safety, the distinction that matters is not open versus closed, but transparent and secure versus opaque and unexamined. Open models and open tooling should be recognized as defensive assets...
    more AI Verified source (Jul 27, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Jakob Foerster
    Associate professor at the University of Oxford and co-director of the British Open-ended Learning and Discovery Lab
    votes Against and says:
    BOLD is about a different route: discovering fundamentally new ways to build AI that are more efficient, more open and better aligned with human needs.
    AI Verified source (Jun 23, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Vince McMullin
    Co-founder and CEO of CanXP AI, a Canadian sovereign-AI platform.
    votes Against and says:
    Release the Fable 5 weights under a responsible open-weight framework. Provide meaningful training-corpus disclosure. Create audited access pathways for independent researchers and sovereign AI operators. Allow the public to verify safety claims rath...
    more AI Verified source (Jun 11, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 2mo ago
    Info
  • Kanishka Narayan
    UK Minister for AI and Online Safety; Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
    votes Against and says:
    The best AI tools in the world won’t be built behind closed doors by a handful of companies. They’ll be built by people who ship code, share it, and let others make it better.
    AI Verified source (Jun 10, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    Open innovation is foundational to AI progress, and broad access to models, data, and tools is essential to accelerating breakthroughs. By adopting the Linux Foundation’s OpenMDW framework for NVIDIA open model families, we’re helping establish a sim...
    more AI Verified source (May 28, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Hanna Hajishirzi
    Professor at the University of Washington and senior director of NLP at Ai2
    votes Against and says:
    These days you might argue that progress in AI is getting limited into a few closed labs, but it’s actually very important to the vast majority of academia and researchers, or nonprofit and other places who want to also be part of this progress. And ...
    more AI Verified source (Mar 25, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    We believe that open-wide models should be the basis for building all the AI software in the world. By having an open ecosystem of people that have aligned incentives to create assets that are going to be great for humanity, we can accelerate progres...
    more AI Verified source (Mar 25, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Misha Laskin
    Co-founder and CEO of Reflection AI; artificial intelligence researcher
    votes Against and says:
    Models are fundamental knowledge infrastructure, and fundamental knowledge infrastructure yearns for openness. There’s a flourishing ecosystem of powerful, closed models but equally capable open models that are going to be coming over the next couple...
    more AI Verified source (Mar 25, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • John deVadoss
    AI technologist; co-founder of NeuralFabric and former Microsoft general manager
    votes Against and says:
    We cannot meaningfully regulate the development of AI in a world where artifacts copy in near real time and research flows fluidly across borders.
    AI Verified source (Feb 2, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Baroness Neville-Jones
    British Conservative life peer and former UK security minister.
    votes Against and says:
    The research community, while they should not be expected to reveal to the world where they have got to, should be in dialogue with government. They need to be required to tell government where they are and what they are doing on the research front.
    AI Verified source (Jan 29, 2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Nuro AI Labs
    London-based AI research lab developing open models and general-intelligence research
    votes Against and says:
    We publish weights, training code and synthetic-data pipelines wherever the research permits. Apache 2.0 is the default. We don't believe the systems on the path to general intelligence should be closed boxes held by three companies.
    AI Verified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Tribela Labs
    European AI research lab focused on open, transparent, privacy-preserving systems
    votes Against and says:
    We believe transparency and open research are not optional — they are the only way to build AI that people can trust, audit, and improve upon. Tribela Labs exists to prove that a sustainable company can advance AI research while keeping its methods t...
    more AI Verified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Frontier Intelligence Labs
    Frontier AI research group founded in 2026 to develop broadly accessible systems
    votes Against and says:
    We’re a research group pushing the frontier of artificial intelligence — and making it useful, affordable, and open to the world. Not the few. Everyone. We do original research at the capability frontier — and publish what we learn instead of locking...
    more AI Verified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Tertium AI
    Nonprofit building and distributing frontier AI with open-by-default governance
    votes Against and says:
    We’re open by default: open code; open data, subject to privacy and copyright; and open weights wherever responsible. We release as widely as we can demonstrate to be safe.
    AI Verified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Tenzro Foundation
    Public-interest foundation developing open and accountable AI infrastructure
    votes Against and says:
    Research, code, weights, datasets, evaluations, and governance artifacts default to open. Any decision to withhold is published with its rationale, its scope, and the conditions under which it will be revisited.
    AI Verified source (2026)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    All mixtures, filtering rules, and data sources are fully released for reproducibility.
    AI Verified source (Dec 1, 2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    At Eleuther AI, we’ve spent five years working to make large-scale AI research more transparent, accessible, and ethical, with a strong focus on data work.
    AI Verified source (Oct 7, 2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • votes Against and says:
    Open source AI requires: unrestricted access to trained parameters/weights; complete code used to train the system and prepare training data; full dataset (unless legally impossible).
    AI Verified source (Oct 6, 2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Ana Klimovic
    Assistant professor of computer science at ETH Zurich and Swiss AI Initiative steering-committee member
    votes Against and says:
    I’m really excited about the release of the fully open Apertus model and the follow-up work to come.
    AI Verified source (Sep 17, 2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
  • Antoine Bosselut
    Professor at EPFL and co-lead of the Swiss AI Initiative
    votes Against and says:
    Apertus demonstrates that generative AI can be both powerful and open. [...] The release of Apertus is not a final step, rather it’s the beginning of a journey, a long-term commitment to open, trustworthy, and sovereign AI foundations, for the public...
    more AI Verified source (Sep 2, 2025)
    Like Comment Share on X added 3mo ago
    Info
Loading more opinions...